Pet Keen is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Home > Dogs > Adding a Second Dog to Your Family: The Pros & Cons

Adding a Second Dog to Your Family: The Pros & Cons

beagle puppy licking woman's nose

Adding a second dog to your family can bring so much joy and love. It can provide companionship and playtime for both you and your existing pooch. Those are just a couple of the benefits, but there are definitely other pros and cons to consider before bringing home another pup. Let’s take a closer look at the pros and cons in this article.

divider-dog

The 7 Pros of Adding a Second Dog

1. More Playtime

Not only will your pup have more company, but they’ll get to enjoy even more playtime with their new canine companion.

basenji dogs on the grass
Image By: Verbitskaya Juliya, Shutterstock

2. Socialization

Dogs are pack animals and having two pups can help them stay socialized and comfortable around other dogs.


3. Double the Love

Having a second pup means double the love in your home! From cuddles to walks and even snuggling up together on the couch, you’ll get to see your pups bond uniquely.

Senior and young adult dogs enjoying fresh air
Image Credit: Anna Hoychuk, Shutterstock

4. Exercise

Having two dogs can help keep both of your pups active and healthy, as they’ll encourage each other to exercise.


5. Safety in Numbers

When you’re out for walks, having two pups can help make them both feel safer and more secure. Dogs are naturally pack animals, and while they’re also fine being the only dog, they’re instinctively wired to be with other dogs.

an adult woman with hat playing with her dogs in the bedroom
Image Credit: JenRegnier, Pixabay

6. Mental Stimulation

Having two pups can help keep both of them mentally stimulated. Not only will they be able to play together, but you’ll also be able to provide them with different types of toys and activities that will keep their minds engaged.


7. Companionship

Having two pups can help provide companionship and comfort, so they won’t be lonely when you’re away or at work.

two dogs standing behind the gate
Image Credit: Alex Zotov, Shutterstock

divider-dog paw

The 7 Cons of Adding a Second Dog

1. More Expenses

From vet bills to food, toys, and other supplies, having two dogs can certainly mean double the money spent.

feeding dogs
Image Credit: Nadezhda Zaitceva, Shutterstock

2. Training

Dogs need to be trained and socialized, so having two pups can take a lot of time and attention.


3. Separation Anxiety

If one pup has separation anxiety, having another dog might not help the situation much. In fact, it could make it worse as they could become overly attached instead of forming an attachment with their humans.

Chinook dogs
Image Credit: Nick Chase 68, Shutterstock

4. Jealous and Possessive Behavior

Two dogs in the same home can also lead to jealousy and possessive behavior if not properly monitored.


5. House Training

With two dogs, house training can be a lot harder. From accidents to potty breaks, having two pups could mean more messes to clean up than with just one pup.

a-dog-licking-another-dogs-ear
Image Credit: chongha, Shuttestock

6. Puppies!

If you have two dogs (one of each sex) there’s always the chance of surprise puppies! However, this one can be remedied by spaying and neutering the two dogs.


7. Territorial Behavior

Two dogs can also lead to territorial behavior, as one dog may try to establish dominance over the other. It’s important to introduce the two dogs carefully and slowly to lessen some of these behaviors.

two dogs fighting
Image Credit: Katrin B., Pixabay

divider-paw How Do You Know If You’re Ready for a New Dog?

Ultimately, whether you decide to bring a second dog into your home is up to you. You may be ready for a second dog if:

  • You’re prepared for the financial and time commitments.
  • Your existing pup is comfortable around other dogs.
  • Both dogs are as healthy as possible.
  • Your home is ready, and you have the necessary supplies.
  • You have a plan for doing double the work.
  • You have a plan to prevent accidental puppies.

How to Safely Introduce Your Dog to a New Dog

So, let’s say you did it! You got a second dog, or have decided that a second dog is right for you. Let’s talk about what to do next to help ensure a successful meeting.

  • Make sure the transition is done in a safe and controlled environment.
  • Start by keeping them separated at first so they can get used to each other’s smell.
  • Gradually introduce supervised playtime with positive reinforcement for good behavior.
  • Watch for any signs of aggression or stress and make sure to intervene if needed.
  • Take group walks to help establish a pack bond.
  • Reward both dogs for behavior you want to see.
cute collies male and female
Image Credit: stanarchy93, Pixabay

divider-dog paw

Adding a Second Dog to the Family: FAQs

Q: How do I know if my dog is ready for a new pup?

A: First, it’s important to make sure your existing pup is well-socialized and comfortable around other dogs. If they are, then you can start the process of introducing a new pup into the home.

Q: What should I do if my dogs don’t get along?

A: If your pups aren’t getting along, it could be due to lack of socialization or improper introductions. In this case, it’s important to seek the advice of a professional trainer who can help you with behavioral issues.

Q: Is it better to have two dogs of the same breed?

A: Not necessarily. It’s important to consider both the individual personalities and temperaments of your pups as well as their energy levels when deciding if two dogs of the same breed are a good fit for your family.

german shepherd dogs resting in the yard
Image Credit: Ivor Ilic, Pixabay

Q: Is it better to get two dogs of the same sex?

A: Again, this depends on the individual personalities of your pups. It’s important to consider both the energy levels and temperaments of your dogs when making this decision. You also want to consider the risk of puppies and whether you want to have your dogs spayed and neutered.

Q: How do I handle potty training two dogs?

A: Potty training two pups can be tricky, so it’s important to remain consistent and patient. Start by designating a specific area for each pup to go potty and make sure they have regular scheduled bathroom breaks. Monitor their progress closely and be prepared to reward good behavior and correct any accidents that occur.

Q: How do I make sure my dogs get along?

A: The key to having two happy and healthy pups is to ensure they are well-socialized and comfortable around each other. Provide plenty of supervised playtime, positive reinforcement for good behavior, and have patience when introducing your new pup. If you notice any signs of aggression or stress, make sure to intervene and seek the advice of a professional if needed.

Q: Are there any potential health risks of having two dogs?

A: Yes, there are potential health risks when having two dogs. Be sure to check in with your vet regularly to make sure both pups have the necessary vaccinations and preventive care. Additionally, a new dog can cause your existing dog stress as he or she adjusts. Keep an eye out for signs of stress, such as changes in eating or sleeping habits.

dog owner talking to vet
Image Credit: SeventyFour, Shutterstock

Q: What are some tips for managing two dogs?

A: One of the best things you can do to manage two pups is to establish a solid routine. Make sure each pup has his own designated area and toys, as well as regular bathroom breaks and playtime. Additionally, try to feed them separately and be sure they each get plenty of exercise and attention. Finally, take group walks with your two pups to help them bond and establish a strong pack dynamic.

Q: Are there any special considerations when caring for two dogs?

A: Yes, when caring for two pups it’s important to consider their individual needs. Be sure to provide plenty of mental and physical stimulation and make sure they each get enough attention from you. Additionally, it’s important to stay on top of health care needs and make sure both dogs are up to date on vaccinations.

Don’t Forget to Spay or Neuter!

It’s important to remember to spay or neuter your pup before bringing home a second dog. Two dogs of the opposite sex is the recipe for puppies, so unless you want to go from two dogs to a dozen, make sure to spay or neuter! This will help prevent any behavioral issues related to mating as well as help reduce the risk of homeless animals ending up in shelters.

dog ongoing spaying surgery
Image Credit: ARVD73, Shutterstock

divider-dog

Conclusion

Adding a second pup to your family can be a big decision but can also be incredibly rewarding. It’s important to make sure you’re prepared for the extra expenses and time commitment that comes with having two dogs in the home. When done right, adding another pup to your pack can mean double the love, companionship, and fun. Good luck!


Featured Image Credit: Stock-Holm, Shutterstock

Our vets

Want to talk to a vet online?

Whether you have concerns about your dog, cat, or other pet, trained vets have the answers!

Our vets