The Doberman is an old breed first bred in 1890 as a protection dog. The tax collector, Louis Dobermann, wanted a highly intelligent, loyal, and easily trained dog that was agile and limber. The American Doberman Pincher lives up to this vision: its sleek and streamlined body ends in a narrow muzzle and intense eyes, while the European variation is more muscular. The “heavy-set” European Dobie is exclusively bred in Europe and conforms to the FCI (Fédération Cynologique Internationale) standards.

Visual Differences

At a Glance

American Doberman Overview

The American Doberman conforms to the AKC (American Kennel Club) ¹ breed standards in both looks and temperament. It’s a dog ideally suited to family life as it is more placid and homely than its European counterparts, yet it still has its merits as a working dog.

Personality / Character

The American Doberman is intelligent, bright, and sharp. It is a family-oriented dog that wants to share the sofa with its owners and loves a cuddle, despite its intimidating appearance. Most American Dobies are loyal to their owners, with one family member usually being the “favorite,” although the whole family is protected and kept safe.

If they are allowed to get bored, however, the American Doberman can become destructive, aggressive, and snappy, and they require a lot of mental stimulation due to their high intelligence.

Training

The American Doberman is easy to train and is always willing to please. It’s one of the most intelligent breeds in the world and is ranked as the 5th most intelligent dog breed in obedience and first in general trainability ¹ . The American variant is not as headstrong as the European one and, as such, can take to learning new commands well.

They were often used as police dogs due to their high trainability, and modern Dobies are happy to follow commands to the letter as long as praise and affection are given out afterward.

Health & Care

American Dobermans suffer from congenital health problems, which can considerably shorten the dog’s life span.

American Doberman breeders will often genetically test for these illnesses and won’t breed from dogs with these conditions. However, conditions such as GDV and osteosarcoma are more random and cannot be tested for.

Because of these, good pet insurance is recommended to help cover any illnesses or injuries your Dobie may face.

Exercise

The American Doberman needs around an hour of exercise daily since it is a medium breed. Their high intelligence and agile frames mean that high-intensity exercise is tolerated well, and an American Dobie who’s allowed to use their nose while out on a walk will benefit greatly from the body and mind workout this provides.

Suitable for:

The American Doberman variant is suited for active families who still enjoy a dog that loves to cuddle. They are more laid back than the European type and are generally smaller and sleeker. However, they still require an hour or so of exercise a day to keep them stimulated. Owners with experience with working dogs will do well with an American Doberman, and families with older children won’t find a better breed for a devoted family pet.

European Doberman Overview

The European Doberman is a slightly larger, more muscular alternative to the American variant, which is primarily bred out of Europe. This Dobie is held to the FCI’s breed standards and is broader in the chest and features, which suits it well as a working protection dog.

Personality / Character

The European Doberman is strong in every way: fiercely loyal, strong-willed, and physically imposing, despite being a medium dog. However, don’t let this sway you into thinking that this dog doesn’t have the brains behind the brawn, as the European Doberman is just as intelligent as its American cousin.

The European Doberman is more stalwart and unshakable than the American version. They are still used as protection dogs that need a level and non-reactive temperament until a reaction is necessary to keep the family safe.

They are loyal, doting and excellent workers, using their bright and sharp minds to carry out any tasks asked of them.

Exercise

European Dobermans need slightly more exercise than their American counterparts due in part to their higher drive and energy levels. This stems from their lineage, as European Dobermans are mostly bred for working protection and unwavering focus. They are only slightly more muscular and generally larger, but they can become easily bored and destructive if their physical exercise needs aren’t met.

Training

The European Doberman has the same sharp intellect as the American Dobie and is included in the breed’s overall ranking of 5th most intelligent dog breed in the world. Training a European Dobie should be easy, as their desire to please and sharp minds afford them the drive to be as obedient as possible. They may need more firm direction than the American Dobie, but positive reinforcement and showing them that they’ve done well will always go a long way when training these loyal dogs.

Health & Care

Unfortunately, the European Doberman suffers from the same congenital conditions as the American Dobie. These are inherited disorders that can be tested for, and they are also more likely to suffer from illnesses that aren’t inherited but that occur randomly.

These, unfortunately, can all lower the dog’s lifespan.

Suitable for:

The European Doberman is more suitable for families with older children who are well-versed in keeping strong-willed working dogs. The European Dobie is no less affectionate than the American variant but requires more exercise and training to keep them happy and calm. These dogs are unsuitable for a sedentary family or a family who wants a lap dog since they are highly energetic and thrive on routine and reward.

American vs European Doberman Coloring

The American and European Dobermans have the same distinctive tan markings on their bodies, with their expressive eyebrows, check blazes, and cheeks being the most recognizable. There are differences in color between them, however, at least according to the breed standards.

The AKC accepts a wider range of colors in their breed standard, which differs from the FCI’s.

However, the FCI states that only black and tan and brown and tan colors may be permitted. There are several instances of white Dobermans that aren’t albino. This is a deformation and causes lots of health problems for the dogs, including temperament issues, blindness, and deafness. Breeding white Dobermans (of either variety) is shunned for this reason, as it’s irresponsible and causes suffering o the dogs.

Which Breed Is Right for You?

Which Doberman variant is right for you depends on why you want a dog. If you want a family pet that is easily trained, protective, good with children, and loves a relaxing evening on the sofa, the American Doberman is absolutely for you.

If you’d prefer a hard-working, loyally devoted working dog that is strong-willed and razor-sharp, the European Doberman is for you.

However, this doesn’t mean that the American can’t be a dutiful watchdog and the European can’t be a loving family pet. These are just the lifestyles each breed would suit best, and either way, both variants will thrive most on love, care, and affection from their family.

Featured Image Credit: Top – PedroTello, Shutterstock | Bottom – GracefulFoto, Shutterstock