With the right cat litter, you can turn the odorous, dust cloud in the corner of a room into a neutral smelling kitty haven. A good choice of litter is inoffensive to you and the rest of your family, easy to clean out, and won’t leave your cat and your family gasping for breath after inhaling a lungful of clay dust.
When choosing cat litter, there is a huge selection to pick from, including clumping and non-clumping, scented and unscented, and those made from materials ranging from clay to silica gel and even corn husks.
To help you find the best cat litter for your home, we have compiled reviews of 10 of the best products for your litter tray.
A Glance at Our Top Choices in 2023
|Best Overall||World’s Best Clumping Cat Litter||
|Best Value||Dr. Elsey’s Precious Cat Litter||
|Premium Choice||Fresh Step Crystal Cat Litter||
|Tidy Cats Clumping Clay Cat Litter||
|Arm & Hammer Clay Cat Litter||
The 10 Best Cat Litters
1. World’s Best Unscented Clumping Corn Cat Litter – Best Overall
The World’s Best Unscented Clumping Corn Cat Litter is widely heralded as being the best litter. It is affordable, although not the cheapest on our list. It is low dust, although not entirely dust-free, and it clumps quickly.
It does everything well, but it is especially good at controlling odors while its quick clumping nature means that if you scoop the contents out regularly, you do not have to do a full change every day and a bag of the litter will last you for some time.
World’s Best has a good range of litters including those designed for multi-cat and single cat households, and there’s even a lavender scented option. However, it’s the standard litter that we found to be the best overall cat litter because it foregoes the unnatural smell added to some litter brands and relies on doing a good job of removing the smell of urine and poop instead. The use of corn means that it is an environmentally friendly option, too.
All in all, we think this is the overall best cat litter available this year.
2. Dr. Elsey’s Precious Cat Clumping Clay Cat Litter – Best Value
If you are looking for the best cat litter for the money, Dr. Elsey’s Precious Cat Ultra Unscented Clumping Clay Cat Litter is not only very affordable but the traditional clay material clumps quickly and forms a long-lasting clump, too. This also makes it one of the best cat litters for picky cats. For a clay formula, the dust clouds aren’t too bad, but you should expect a little dust and some minor tracking of the clay pieces. Also, like most clay litters, it goes really solid when it gets wet, which means that you will have your work cut out for you when it comes to cleaning the litter tray each week.
Clay litter has pros and cons. It does form strong and long-lasting clumps that are easy to remove from the litter without having to empty everything. It is also inexpensive.
However, it shouldn’t be flushed, it produces some dust, and will track on your kitty’s paws. It is also a chore to clean the solid clumps from the litter tray because they really do clump solid.
3. Fresh Step Scented Crystal Cat Litter – Premium Choice
Fresh Step Scented Non-Clumping Crystal Cat Litter is expensive when compared to clay and materials like wood. However, crystal cat litter is known for locking in smells, which means less odor from your cat litter tray. Crystals also produce minimal dust, which not only makes them suitable for cats and owners with asthma and bronchial disorders but makes the area around the cat litter less toxic.
The crystals are non-clumping but highly absorbent. The individual crystals increase in size when they get wet, which means that they can be sifted using a scooper, still enabling you to remove soiled litter and leaving the clean litter in place without having to empty and replace the full tray.
Unfortunately, while this crystal litter can do a good job of preventing the smell of urine and they do not produce dust, they don’t catch all the urine so you will find a puddle at the bottom of the tray and the lightweight litter does track through the house.
4. Purina Tidy Cats Strong Unscented Clumping Clay Cat Litter
|Container Type:||Multipack Bags|
Purina Tidy Cats Naturally Strong Unscented Clumping Clay Cat Litter is another inexpensive clay litter. It uses activated charcoal as a means of trapping odors and preventing the smell of urine and feces from traveling around the house.
The litter quickly forms tight clumps, which are easy to scoop out, while the odor control prevents you from having to do a complete clean too often. Purina also claims that the formula is dust-free, so you don’t get a face full of clay dust when you fill the tray.
It is also better for asthmatic and allergic cats. The litter is quite heavy, which is both a curse and a blessing. Heavier litter does not track as easily but is more challenging to lug around and pour in the tray. Also, despite claims, it does produce quite a dust cloud when it is being poured into the tray. It does not clump together when wet as well as other clay formulae, either.
5. Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Scented Clumping Cat Litter
Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Multi-Cat Scented Clumping Clay Cat Litter is a clay litter and is designed for households with multiple cats. Such households endure a large amount of urine and solids, and they need a litter that can work to control a lot of odor still without having to be emptied and replaced too frequently. Arm & Hammer claims that their proprietary micro-granules quickly form a very tight seal around urine, therefore preventing smells while negating the need to have to frequently change the whole litter tray. The microparticles are also designed to be softer on your cat’s paws. If a cat feels uncomfortable or endures any discomfort while in the litter tray, they may choose to relieve themselves next to the tray instead of inside it. The litter is designed to provide odor protection for up to 7 days and is one of the cheaper litter options on our list.
The litter produces minimal dust, but it does track through the house. Baking soda does not do the best job of covering up smells, and the litter won’t last one week in most multi-cat households.
6. Frisco Unscented Odor Defense Clay Cat Litter – Best Cat Litter for Picky Cats
For most picky cats, Frisco Unscented Odor Defense Clay Cat Litter is the best option. It has an odor-defense technology that prevents ammonia smells from becoming overwhelming. There are no fragrances, perfumes, or dyes included, which is helpful for picky cats. It is also helpful for humans with sensitive noses, since fragrances can often be overwhelming.
This litter is made out of clay, which most cats have no problem with. It clumps and absorbs liquids quickly. Therefore, it makes scooping and cleaning much easier, and the ammonia smell doesn’t have an opportunity to permeate the air.
The clumps also use less litter, saving you money over time. This litter does not create huge clumps like some other litters do.
As a low-dust formula, this litter is perfect for cats sensitive to dust, and it won’t make respiratory illnesses worse. Due to these features, this is easily the best overall cat litter for picky cats.
7. Tidy Cats Lightweight Scented Clumping Clay Cat Litter
Tidy Cats Lightweight Glade Scented Clumping Clay Litter from Purina is a moderately priced, lightweight litter. The clay litter uses the air freshener, Glade, to mask the smell of urine and feces. It weighs less than other clay litters and has minimal dust, which means that it is less hassle to pour into the litter box compared to competing brands. Purina claims that the litter prevents the smell of ammonia and urine for up to 14 days and it uses the Clear Springs Glade scent.
However, the addition of Glade is not welcomed by all, with complaints of a strong chemical smell, and a price increase. The unnatural scent of perfumes and fresheners can deter some cats from using the box, and you may find the number of accidents around the litter box increases in these cases. Also, the lightweight formula does not work as well at collecting urine, and it can turn into a mushy mess when used.
8. Dr. Elsey’s Precious Cat Attract Clumping Clay Cat Litter
Dr. Elsey’s Precious Cat Attract Clumping Clay Cat Litter is different from most litters on this list. It is designed for cats that are struggling to get to grips with going in the litter tray. It uses a natural herb that is said to attract cats, therefore encouraging cats to use the litter tray when nature calls. Every bag also contains a book that includes instructions on teaching your cat to effectively use the litter tray.
The litter itself is a clay litter that clumps quickly and forms a solid bond. It is 99% dust-free, and compatible with mechanical litter boxes. The litter does a good job of attracting cats and can work to minimize accidents outside the litter box. It is also a reasonable price but it does suffer in some other regards.
Urine soaks through to the bottom of the tray and the smell that attracts the cats is quite strong so may be enough to put you off using it in the first place. What’s more, it is dustier than claimed.
9. sWheat Scoop Unscented Clumping Wheat Cat Litter
sWheat Scoop Multi-Cat Unscented Clumping Wheat Cat Litter is another unusual litter, this time for the material that it is made from. Litter can be made from materials that range from crystals to clay. Environmentally friendly materials have become increasingly popular, and sWheat Scoop, as the name implies, is made from wheat.
The unscented litter utilizes wheat’s natural smell and properties so it is ultra-absorbent and considered suitable for houses with multiple cats. It can even be flushed, although you should always follow instructions before flushing used litter, and bear in mind that doing so is prohibited in some areas, regardless of whether the manufacturer claims it is possible or not. It is more expensive than clay litters but costs less than crystal litters, and it is naturally dust-free.
However, it does track badly, so you may need to clean up around the tray more often. Also, it doesn’t clump particularly well, so you will have to work harder to remove soiled patches or replace the whole tray more often.
10. Okocat Original Premium Wood Clumping Cat Litter
Okocat Original Premium Wood Clumping Cat Litter is made from sustainably sourced wood fiber. Rather than the perfumed and even chemical smell of some litters, wood litter has a natural smell and it does a reasonable job of covering the odors of cat urine, feces, and ammonia.
What’s more, local bylaws permitting, it is flushable.
The plant-based material is 99% dust-free, having been de-dusted, and Okocat claims that it naturally clumps to prevent smell and make cleanup easier. It is reasonably priced for a natural litter.
However, despite the company’s claims, it does produce a lot of dust and it drags through on your cat’s claws and in their fur so it tracks badly. Also, while the litter smells natural and fresh when it is fresh, it doesn’t do a great job of covering urine smells.
Buyer’s Guide: Choosing the Best Cat Litter
There are a lot of options when it comes to choosing cat litter. This means that it is possible to find the right product for your specific requirements, but it also makes it more challenging to sift through the options and decide which material is best, whether you want a clumping litter, and whether you want an unscented litter or something that is enhanced with a Glade air-freshener to create a better smelling local litter environment.
Below are some of the most important factors to look at when deciding on the best cat litter for you and your cat.
Once upon a time, if you wanted cat litter, you lined a tray with newspaper and then poured sand over the top.
- You may also like: 10 Best Litter Boxes for a Small Apartment: Reviews & Top Picks
Clumping or Non-Clumping
Litter is described as being clumping on non-clumping.
Clumping litter will stick together when it gets wet, effectively creating a ball. These balls envelope odor, preventing the escape of urine and ammonia smells, and they are easier to lift out of the tray using a scooper, negating the need to have to replace the entire tray of litter each time.
Non-clumping litter is usually more absorbent so it will swell as it gets wet, but it won’t form a clump. Most litters are clumping because of the convenience and ease, but non-clumping alternatives do exist.
Scented or Unscented
Scented cat litter includes some form of perfume or another scent to help mask the smell of urine and feces. Common options can include natural scents like pine, but there is an increasing number of litter companies that have partnered with air freshener companies, like Glade, to incorporate chemical fresheners. Some people appreciate the perfumed scent, which is freshened every time your car scratches, but some cats do not like the strong chemical smell in the tray which can lead to more accidents.
Clay litter is heavy, which means that it takes effort to lug the bag around and can be difficult to pour from the container. It also means that the litter tray itself is quite heavy. For some people, this weight isn’t a problem, but others prefer lightweight litter. Lightweight materials are easier to lift and store, but they do tend to get stuck in your cat’s fur and claws more easily, causing the litter to track more readily.
Some cat litters may be described as dust-free. Dust is especially a problem with clay litters. As the clay sits in the bag, the tiny particles on the outside of the litter gather at the bottom of the bag, and when you open and pour the contents out, this can form a dust cloud.
This cloud can be quite damaging to cats and people that suffer from asthma or respiratory problems, and some people simply don’t like the idea of cat litter dust around their house. Look for dust-free, minimal dust, and de-dusted options to avoid these clouds.
World’s Best Unscented Clumping Corn Cat Litter is a great combination of affordability and good quality litter that clumps and masks smells, making it our overall best cat litter. If you are looking to spend less, we found Dr. Elsey’s Precious Cat Unscented litter offered the best value for money.
Hopefully, our reviews have helped you find the litter that best meets your needs, whether you value lightweight, dust-free, or any other litter feature.
Featured Image Credit: Africa Studio, Shutterstock