Pet Keen is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Home > Dogs > 10 Best Indestructible Dog Toys in 2024 – Reviews & Top Picks

10 Best Indestructible Dog Toys in 2024 – Reviews & Top Picks

Dog Biting Benebone

Dogs chew naturally at every stage of their lives. Puppies chew to relieve teething pain, and older dogs chew to keep their teeth strong, clean, and healthy. Dogs of all ages can chew to relieve boredom and anxiety and may destroy shoes or furniture if they don’t have a toy to play with. Regardless of where our pups get their destructive impulses from, it’s still frustrating to watch them harm our belongings. If you have a dog that chews everything you buy, we have some solutions for you. You need a sturdy toy your dog won’t rip apart in less than a minute, and our reviews have got you covered. Our goal is to help you make a wise decision and find an indestructible toy for your slavering beast.divider-paw

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2024

Image Product Details
Best Overall
Winner
Benebone Bacon Flavored Benebone Bacon Flavored
  • Delicious bacon flavor
  • Helps satisfy your dog’s natural urge to chew
  • Product and all packaging are made in the USA
  • Best Value
    Second place
    Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball
  • High-bouncing balls
  • Quality materials will float in the water
  • The perfect fetch toy
  • Premium Choice
    Third place
    Tuffy’s Dinosaur Triceratops Tuffy’s Dinosaur Triceratops
  • Silent play with no squeakers
  • Floats in water
  • Easy to clean, machine washable
  • Best for Puppies
    KONG Puppy Dog Toy KONG Puppy Dog Toy
  • Establish proper chewing and playing habits
  • Stuff with snacks for longer-lasting play
  • Soothes teething puppies’ gums
  • KONG Extreme Dog Toy KONG Extreme Dog Toy
  • Fill with snacks for longer play
  • Rubber is tough and durable
  • Dishwasher and freezer safe
  • The 10 Best Indestructible Dog Toys

    1. Benebone Bacon Flavored Wishbone Chew Toy – Best Overall

    Benebone Bacon

    Dimensions: 1.75 x 4.5 x 9 inches
    Weight: 6 ounces
    Toy Scent: Bacon
    Material: Nylon

    Many humans love bacon, and most dogs enjoy it too, which is why the Benebone Bacon Flavored Wishbone Chew Toy stands out from the rest as the best overall indestructible dog toy. These paw-friendly wishbones are made of sturdy nylon, so your dog can chew happily for ages. The durable construction provides hours of safe and tasty chewing fun for your four-legged friend. With food-grade bacon flavoring embedded inside grooves on each prong, your dog will be enthralled. Your pooch is sure to take to this toy quickly and its ergonomic shape makes it a pleasure to chew, as well as being one of the toughest bones available. You can feel good about your purchase, knowing that Benebone also donates a portion of all sales to animal charities.

    Pros
    • Dogs will love its ergonomic design
    • Delicious bacon flavor
    • Helps satisfy your dog’s natural urge to chew
    • Product and all packaging are made in the USA
    • A portion of all Benebone sales goes to animal shelters
    Cons
    • Heavy material can be noisy on hardwood floors

    2. Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Tough Dog Toy – Best Value

    Chuckit

    Dimensions: 2.55 x 5.438 x 6.563 inches
    Weight: 8 ounces
    Toy Scent: Unscented
    Material: Rubber

    If your dog loves to chase and fetch, but punctures and destroys balls very quickly, then check out the Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Tough Dog Toy. These are wonderful for tiring out your dog, as the balls are super high bouncing, and will keep traveling long after they’ve left the launcher. Easy to wipe off, but hard to destroy, these balls are a fantastic alternative to tennis balls. Much stronger and more durable, owners find that they last for months, even with the most aggressive chewers. Made from natural rubber, these have the advantage of floating on water. Their bright colors also make them easy to find and ideal for evening or nighttime play. We think this is the best indestructible dog toy for the money.

    Pros
    • High-bouncing balls
    • Quality materials will float in the water
    • The perfect fetch toy
    • Bright colors are easier to spot and harder to lose
    • Fits Chuckit! launching devices
    Cons
    • Some people report a sweet smell to these

    3. Tuffy’s Dinosaur Triceratops Plush Dog Toy – Premium Choice

    Tuffy's

    Dimensions: 6.5 x 29 x 14 inches
    Weight: 2.8 pounds
    Toy Scent: None
    Material: Polyester, Fleece

    With heavy-chewing dogs, most soft toys go from pristine to a snowstorm of stuffing in minutes. Although this triceratops toy is quite pricey, it is supersized, sturdy, and a lot of fun. This is a weighty, sizeable toy, ideal for active play. One or more dogs can grip, shake, and tug on the Tuffy’s Dinosaur Triceratops Plush Dog Toy. Its unique construction with three different kinds of safe, non-toxic textiles includes soft fleece, industrial luggage material, and plastic coating. These multiple fabrics are bonded and sewn together to form one unique super-strong layer, ensuring long-term durability and fun play time. Additionally, this product floats in water, and is easy to clean since it is machine washable. There are no squeakers included in the construction of this toy, which many owners may see as an advantage!

    Pros
    • Silent play with no squeakers
    • Dogs enjoy it because of its large size
    • Floats in water
    • Easy to clean, machine washable
    Cons
    • Too large for small dogs

    4. KONG Puppy Dog Toy – Best for Puppies

    KONG Puppy

    Dimensions: 1.75 x 1.75 x 3 inches
    Weight: 5 ounces
    Toy Scent: Unscented
    Material: Rubber

    With its special, naturally derived rubber formula, the KONG Puppy Dog Toy is the softest in the KONG rubber toy collection. Puppy mouths are more sensitive: their 28 baby teeth are more fragile and more easily cracked, and their sensitive gums are more easily injured. The softer texture of the teething toy helps teach appropriate chewing behavior and provides an outlet for the instinctive need to gnaw and bite. The design also features a hole which can be stuffed with treats such as kibble or peanut butter, providing a source of fascination and distraction when you need to keep your pal occupied. On a hot summer’s day, you could even freeze a treat inside to really draw out the fun of playtime for your furry friend. As a bonus, the asymmetric design of this line creates an erratic bounce and unpredictable play, which your little buddy is sure to love.

    Pros
    • Active puppies will love its bounces
    • Establish proper chewing and playing habits
    • Stuff with snacks for longer-lasting play
    • Soothes teething puppies’ gums
    Cons
    • Take care to order the right size, as these are much smaller than full size toys

    5. KONG Extreme Dog Toy

    Dimensions: 3 x 1.75 x 2 inches to 6 x 3.9 x 3.5 inches
    Weight: Varies by size
    Toy Scent: Unscented
    Material: Rubber

    Challenger your toughest chewers with the KONG Extreme Dog Toy. This is the grown-up, maximum durability version of the toy reviewed above. It features all the same great experiences: because of its irregular shape, when thrown it bounces unpredictably; it can be filled with treats to stimulate and reward play; and most crucially, robust, all-natural rubber means this toy is a match for the strongest jaws. After a play session, if there are any leftover food particles, simply rinse them out or clean them in the dishwasher.

    Pros
    • Fill with snacks for longer play
    • Rubber is tough and durable
    • Dishwasher and freezer safe
    Cons
    • When filled with food it can create a mess

    6. Monster K9 Dog Toys Indestructible Flying Disc Dog Toy

    Monster K9 Dog Toys Indestructible Flying Disc Dog Toy

    Dimensions: 8.5 x 8.5 x 1.5 inches
    Weight: 8 ounces
    Toy Scent: Unscented
    Material: Rubber

    Pups that like to run, jump, and catch will love the K9 Dog Toys Ultra-Durable Flying Disc Dog Toy. Cheap, plastic frisbees tend to only last one or two sessions with heavy-chewing breeds; this disk should last longer. As a result of its natural rubber construction, its aerodynamically smooth surface is puncture resistant. As it contains only non-toxic materials, this is a safe way to keep your dog active. Although we think this is a sturdy product, and the best of the flying disks available, some people find that their dogs can destroy it if allowed the time and opportunity to freely chew on it. That’s why we recommend monitoring your dog’s playtime and only bringing out this toy for active frisbee play.

    Pros
    • Flying toy that can withstand rough play
    • Reinforced with natural rubber
    • Smooth surface for easy gliding
    • Safe and non-toxic materials
    Cons
    • Can get torn up if you leave your dog unsupervised
    • Best to use for frisbee time and then remove

    7. Ruff Dawg Indestructible Dawg Nut Tough Dog Chew Toy

    Ruff Dawg

    Dimensions: 3.5 x 3.5 x 1.5 inches
    Weight: 12.8 ounces
    Toy Scent: Unscented
    Material: Rubber

    The Ruff Dawg Indestructible Dawg Nut Dog Toy is another wonderful fetch toy. With a springy texture and a mouthfeel your pup is sure to enjoy, it also floats, bounces, and is simple to wash clean. Its FDA-approved solid rubber construction helps it stand up to some chompers; however, the most aggressive chewers can take chunks out of this toy, and pretty rapidly, too. The toy may also be able to withstand interactive play, but we think it shouldn’t be left to gnaw on by your dog.

    Pros
    • Free of phthalates, latex, and BPAs
    • Springy bite
    • Easy to rinse
    Cons
    • Can be torn up by the most aggressive dogs
    • Best to put away after a game of fetch

    8. Mammoth Cotton Blend 3 Knot Dog Rope Toy

    Dimensions: 20 x 4.13 x 3 inches
    Weight: 12.8 ounces
    Toy Scent: Unscented
    Material: 100% natural cotton

    The Mammoth Cotton Blend 3 Knot Dog Rope Toy will floss dogs’ teeth as they chew and play. Although this is one of the strongest rope toys on the market, it will still eventually rip apart, and can be messy as it sheds fibers. However, dogs really enjoy gripping and shaking rope toys back and forth, so it may be worth it to you to give your best friend this experience. Be aware that this frantic swinging motion can be dangerous around small children—the lash or the rope will sting. On the plus side, this is another toy that is easy to clean. To remove bacteria, mold, and yeast, it can be put through the dishwasher or soaked and then placed in the microwave. Regardless of how you decide to launder it, make sure you let it cool down completely before returning it to your buddy.

    Pros
    • Made with natural cotton
    • Rope fibers floss dogs’ teeth
    • Easy to clean
    Cons
    • Can be pulled apart or gnawed through by stubborn dogs
    • Dogs can injure small children when shaking the rope

    9. Arm & Hammer Dental Super Treadz Tough Dog Chew Toy

    Dimensions: 2.31 x 4.252 x 8.75 inches
    Weight: 9.07 ounces
    Toy Scent: Baby powder
    Material: Rubber

    With a bright and fun design, this Arm & Hammer Super Treadz Dental Dog Toy keeps your dog’s teeth clean while they play. Your canine companion will love this sturdy toy, designed to freshen breath, stimulate gums, and reduce tartar and plaque build-up. The baking soda-infused rubber shell scrubs and deodorizes your pet’s mouth while keeping them happily entertained for hours. It is simple to clean and can be thrown in the dishwasher as necessary. However, some people say they can’t stand the baby powder smell of this gorilla. Others find the treat dispenser function quite difficult to operate.

    Pros
    • Removes plaque, tartar, and freshens breath
    • Funky color and design
    Cons
    • The baby powder smell bothers some people
    • It is difficult to operate the treat dispenser
    • Not suitable for the most energetic chewers

    10. Nylabone Power Chew Bacon Flavored Dog Chew Toy

    Nylabone Power Chew

    Dimensions: 8 x 4.5 x 1.5 inches
    Weight: 9.07 ounces
    Toy Scent: Bacon
    Material: Nylon

    If your dog loves the flavor and toughness of rawhide and bones, but you don’t enjoy the cleanup, the Nylabone Power Chew is another wonderful bacon flavored chew toy. Made from tough, durable nylon, this type of toy offers a mess-free alternative to real animal parts. Your paw-tners gnawing action has the benefit of cleaning their teeth and freshening their breath. This toy does seem to be hit and miss: some dogs seem disinterested, while others love it. One concern is that in the most aggressive jaws, it may splinter into sharp pieces and so could cut your dog’s mouth. Although this happens rarely, we consider this to be a major drawback in an otherwise wonderful product, which is why it’s last on our list of reviews.

    Pros
    • Freshens breath, cleans teeth, and promotes oral health
    • Bacon flavored chewiness
    Cons
    • Some dogs are disinterested
    • Potentially splinters into sharp pieces

    divider-paw

    Buyer’s Guide – Finding the Best Indestructible Dog Toy

    You have to think about your dog’s preferences when choosing the right dog toys. If your dog likes to fetch, they’ll need a waterproof toy that can fit comfortably in their mouth. If your dog is a snack hunter, a dog toy with treats inside might be a good idea. If your dog likes to play-fight, wrestle, or tussle, they might enjoy a soft toy or rope toy. When choosing dog toys for aggressive chewing dogs, there are other factors to consider besides the type of play involved.

    What Types of Materials Should I Look For?

    Toys for destructive dogs should be made of sturdy, high-quality materials. An indestructible dog toy can be made of nylon, double-knit rope, or natural rubber. You should also consider the construction of the toy: seams should be double or triple stitched, materials should be non-toxic, and any glue or fixative used must be safe for your dog.

    What Size Dog Toy Should I Buy?

    It is important to ensure that your tough dog toy is the appropriate size and weight for your pet. The toy may become a choking risk if it is too small or if it can easily be torn into small parts. It could damage their jaws or teeth if it is too bulky or weighty. A dog may also ignore a toy that is too big for them, if they cannot comfortably control it while playing or chewing.

    What Materials Are Safe for Dogs?

    An FDA-approved toy is a good indication that a particular toy is safe for your dog. Beyond this, always try to choose non-toxic toys. This will mean avoiding plastics and choosing materials that are free of heavy metals, PVC, BPAs, and phthalates. Likewise, it is a good idea to avoid toys made of cheap materials or with parts that can easily be chewed off or split apart. Even non-toxic toys can become hazardous as they break down: stitching can come apart and get stuck in their teeth or hurt their gums; smaller pieces may cut your dog’s mouth or break their teeth; stuffing risks being ingested or choked on. When your dog’s toys start breaking or showing signs of excessive wear, throw them away. divider-paw

    Conclusion

    It’s frustrating when you spend hard-earned money on dog toys, only to see parts of them strewn all over your home minutes later. The Benebone Bacon Flavored Wishbone Chew Toy is a delicious and long-lasting chewy treat that all dogs will love. For a tough, hard-wearing upgrade on the tennis ball, try out the Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Tough Dog Toy. Whatever type of play your best friend prefers, we hope you’ll find the indestructible dog toy of their dreams in our reviews.

    See Also:


    Featured Image Credit: Chewy

    Our vets

    Want to talk to a vet online?

    Whether you have concerns about your dog, cat, or other pet, trained vets have the answers!

    Our vets