Pet Keen is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Home > Cats > 9 Best Natural & Organic Cat Foods in 2024 – Reviews & Top Picks

9 Best Natural & Organic Cat Foods in 2024 – Reviews & Top Picks

cat eats from a plate with wet cat food

Nutrition is one of the most important parts of pet ownership, especially for cats. Unique environmental circumstances influenced cat evolution and created special dietary needs, such as consuming high portions of meat to survive.

Unfortunately, many commercial cat foods are filled with preservatives, fillers, byproducts, and otherwise questionable ingredients that are not ideal for your cat’s nutritional needs. On top of that, cats can be picky about their food, making it even more difficult to choose natural and healthy options.

Here are our picks and reviews for the best natural and organic cat food.

divider-cat

A Quick Glance of Our Favorites in 2024

Image Product Details
Best Overall
Winner
Smalls Fresh Cat Food Subscription Smalls Fresh Cat Food Subscription
  • Contains taurine
  • Sampler boxes available
  • Contains no fillers or preservatives
  • Budget Buy
    Second place
    Purina Beyond Organic Chicken Purina Beyond Organic Chicken
  • Reasonably priced
  • Contains USDA-certified ingredients
  • Organic chicken is the first ingredient
  • Third place
    Evanger's Organics Braised Chicken Dinner Evanger's Organics Braised Chicken Dinner
  • Carrageenan-free
  • Contains high-protein, organic chicken
  • Packed with antioxidants and nutrition
  • Best for Kittens
    Stella & Chewy's Chicken & Salmon Flavored Pate Stella & Chewy's Chicken & Salmon Flavored Pate
  • No artificial ingredients
  • 100% complete and balanced
  • Developed specifically for kittens
  • Reveal Natural Grain-Free Variety of Fish in Broth Reveal Natural Grain-Free Variety of Fish in Broth
  • Offers a variety of flavors
  • Added fish broth for flavor
  • 100% complete and balanced
  • The 9 Best Natural & Organic Cat Foods

    1. Smalls Fresh Cat Food Subscription – Best Overall

    Food type: Human-grade fresh
    Flavor options: Chicken, turkey, beef, fish
    Lifestage: All
    Sizes: 1-ounce, 5.5-ounce, and 11.5-ounce packages

    Smalls Fresh Cat Food is a subscription service that delivers human-grade cat food right to your door. You can choose between four protein-rich recipes: chicken, turkey, beef, and fish. Whatever your cat’s pallet, Smalls has a recipe; you can select smooth pâté, ground minced, or shredded textures.

    All ingredients are USDA-certified and humanely harvested from trusted sources in the United States and Canada. They are 100% natural, so you know your kitty is getting the best of the best. All recipes are BPA-free and contain no preservatives, fillers, or “mystery” ingredients. This food contains taurine, a vital element in cat nutrition, aiding in everything from vision digestion to heart health. This food exceeds AAFCO’s taurine requirements, and you’ll often see taurine-rich ingredients, such as chicken hearts, in the ingredient list.

    Smalls offers a sampler box to try with 20% off. To get started, you will answer a few questions about your cat, and they will suggest recipes to fit your cat’s needs. We recommend consulting your veterinarian before switching, especially if your cat has a health issue, such as kidney disease. Given the high protein content, it may not be suitable for every cat, and it’s also expensive. However, with the quality ingredients, we feel this food is the best overall natural and organic food.

    Pros
    • Made from trusted sources in the US and Canada
    • 100% all-natural, USDA-certified ingredients
    • Contains taurine
    • Contains no fillers or preservatives
    • Sampler boxes available
    Cons
    • Not suitable for every cat
    • Expensive

    2. Purina Beyond Organic Chicken – Budget Buy

    Purina Beyond Organic Chicken

    Food type: Wet/canned
    Flavor options: Chicken and carrots, chicken and sweet potato
    Lifestage: Adult
    Sizes: 3-ounce cans

    Purina Beyond Organic Chicken offers your beloved feline an organic, non-GMO diet. This particular 6-pack of cans 3-ounce offers two recipes: chicken and carrots and chicken and sweet potato. All cans are pâté style and offer quality USDA-certified ingredients, including organic chicken, organic chicken broth, and organic chicken livers. This food is packed with vitamins and minerals your cat needs daily, and most cats devour this food. The chickens used are free-range with antibiotics or growth hormones, and it does not contain artificial flavors, colors, preservatives, or poultry by-products.

    This cat food comes at a more affordable price for 6 cans, which we feel is the best natural and organic cat food for the money, especially considering organic food is typically more expensive, but some cat owners claim their cats won’t touch it—this food might not work for the picky feline.

    Pros
    • Contains USDA-certified ingredients
    • Organic chicken is the first ingredient
    • Contains no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives
    • Reasonably priced
    Cons
    • Might not work for picky eaters

     


    3. Evanger’s Organics Braised Chicken Dinner

    Evanger's Organics Braised Chicken Dinner

    Food type: Wet/canned
    Flavor options: Chicken
    Lifestage: Adult
    Sizes: 5-ounce can

    Evanger’s Organics Braised Chicken Dinner comes in a case of 24, 5.5-ounce cans. It is made with high-protein, organic chicken and is packed with antioxidants and nutrients to support a healthy immune system. It also includes taurine, a vital component in cat food that aids in vision, digestion, and heart health. This gluten and grain-free organic cat food has omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids for healthy skin and coat, as well as balanced minerals for dental and bone health. This cat food is also carrageenan-free.

    This cat food is a more expensive option, but the quality ingredients are worth the price if they fits your budget. A drawback is the food has a pungent smell, which may deter some cats from eating it.

    Pros
    • Contains high-protein, organic chicken
    • Packed with antioxidants and nutrition
    • Includes fatty acids for healthy skin and coat
    • Includes taurine
    • Carrageenan-free
    Cons
    • Pungent smell
    • Smell may deter some cats

    4. Stella & Chewy’s Chicken & Salmon Flavored Pate – Best for Kittens

    Stella & Chewy's Chicken & Salmon Flavored Pate

    Food type: Wet/canned
    Flavor options: Chicken and salmon
    Lifestage: Kitten
    Sizes: 8-ounce cans or 5.2-ounce cans, case of 24

    If you have a kitten, Stella & Chewy’s Chicken & Salmon Flavored Pate Kitten Wet Cat Food is a good choice. This protein-rich pâté is meaty, tender, and 100% complete and balanced with no added artificial ingredients. It contains DHA for brain and eye health, and it’s specifically developed for growing kittens. It’s free from legumes, grains, potatoes, carrageen, and MSG, and it includes a tasty broth a kitten will love. You can use this food as a complete meal or as a topper with dry kibble.

    The only downfall we see with this food is the expensive price, but remember, your kitten will grow and need a different food once he hits adulthood.

    Pros
    • Developed specifically for kittens
    • Includes DHA for brain and eye health
    • Free from legumes, potatoes, carrageen, and MSG
    • No artificial ingredients
    • 100% complete and balanced
    Cons
    • Expensive

    5. Reveal Natural Grain-Free Variety of Fish in Broth

    Reveal Natural Grain-Free Variety of Fish in Broth

    Food type: Wet/canned
    Flavor options: Tuna filet, ocean fish, tuna filet with seaweed
    Lifestage: Adult
    Sizes: 47-ounce cans, case of 12

    Reveal Natural Grain-Free Variety of Fish in Broth offers your cat a variety at mealtime. These cases of 12, 2.47-ounce cans come with four tuna filet recipes, four ocean fish recipes, and four tuna filet with seaweed recipes. It has limited grain-free and all-natural ingredients with added fish broth to add flavor. It’s 100% complete and balanced, and you can feed it by itself or add it as a topper to dry kibble.

    This food is an excellent option to give your cat a variety of flavors to keep from getting bored, and it’s reasonably priced. However, be aware that there have been reports from consumers of finding fish bones in the food, so it’s wise to check it before feeding your cat.

    Pros
    • Offers a variety of flavors
    • Added fish broth for flavor
    • 100% complete and balanced
    • Limited, all-natural ingredients
    • Reasonably priced
    Cons
    • Watch for fish bones in food

    6. Tender & True Cat Organic Chicken & Liver Cat Food

    Tender & True Cat Food, Organic, Chicken & Liver Dry

    Food type: Dry
    Flavor options: Chicken and liver
    Lifestage: Adult
    Sizes: 3 pounds

    Tender & True Organic Cat Food is a dry cat food that’s grain-free and USDA-certified organic, perfect for optimal cat nutrition. With organic chicken as the first ingredient, this cat food provides the protein your cat needs for strength and energy. The remaining recipe features organic ingredients that supply cats with antioxidants, vitamins, and other nutrients unique to their species-specific needs.

    This dry cat food is free from soy, corn, wheat, artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors. Many reviewers with multiple cats mentioned that finicky cats love this food, saving them from purchasing multiple types of foods to satisfy picky eaters. Some reviewers noticed that their cats with sensitive stomachs got digestive upset, however.

    Pros
    • Organic chicken as the first ingredient
    • Free from soy, corn, wheat, and preservatives
    • Well-rounded nutrition
    Cons
    • Not suitable for cats with sensitive digestion

    7. Castor & Pollux Chicken & Sweet Potato Dry Cat Food

    Castor & Pollux Organix Grain-Free Organic Chicken & Sweet Potato Recipe Dry Cat Food

    Food type: Dry
    Flavor options: Chicken and sweet potato
    Lifestage: Adult
    Sizes: 3 pounds, 6 pounds, 10 pounds

    Like the Castor & Pollux earlier in the list, the Castor & Pollux Organix Grain-Free Organic Chicken & Sweet Potato Recipe Dry Cat Food is a high-quality food made with organic ingredients prepared in an organically certified kitchen. Organic chicken is the first ingredient, followed by a superfood blend of flaxseed, coconut oil, and cranberries.

    This formula differs from the chicken and brown rice formula in that it’s completely free from grains, corn, wheat, or soy. It also contains no synthetic fertilizers, preservatives, growth hormones, or antibiotics. If you’re searching for a grain-free version of the popular Organix chicken and brown rice formula, this organic chicken and sweet potato recipe is a great choice.

    Pros
    • Chicken as the first ingredient
    • Free from grains, wheat, corn, and soy
    • Blend of high-quality superfoods
    Cons
    • More expensive than the brown rice version

    8. Hound & Gatos 98% Chicken & Liver Canned Cat Food

    Hound & Gatos 98% Chicken & Liver Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

    Food type: Wet
    Flavor options: Chicken and liver
    Lifestage: Adult
    Sizes: 5.5-ounce pack of 24 cans

    Hound & Gatos 98% Chicken & Liver Grain-Free Canned Cat Food is a simple, limited-ingredient cat food that features homestyle chicken and chicken liver as the sole protein source. By modeling nutrition after a species-appropriate diet, Hound & Gatos food supplies the nutrition of whole-prey with added vitamins and minerals. The food contains no carbohydrates or preservatives, such as peas, wheat, soy, corn, or gluten.

    Hound & Gatos offers a full line of dry and wet cat food for all life stages and special dietary needs. You can supplement this canned food with the appropriate Hound & Gatos dry food for whole, balanced nutrition for your cat throughout all its life stages.

    Pros
    • Chicken as the first ingredient
    • Species-appropriate nutrition
    Cons
    • Not suitable or sensitive or picky eaters

    9. Stella & Chewy’s Rabbit Dinner Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food

    Stella & Chewy’s Absolutely Rabbit Dinner Morsels Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food

    Food type: Freeze-dried
    Flavor options: Rabbit
    Lifestage: Adult
    Sizes: 3.5-ounce bag, 8-ounce bag, 18-ounce bag

    Stella & Chewy’s Absolutely Rabbit Dinner Morsels Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food gives your cat real meat in a raw, antibiotic-free meal. Irresistible to many cats, this food offers solid protein without added grains or preservatives that upset digestion. To suit cats’ needs, this food contains added taurine for soft fur and healthy skin.

    With its raw form, this food is prepared in small-batch recipes for food safety. Unlike some raw foods, this food doesn’t need to be rehydrated before feeding. Stella & Chewy’s Absolutely Rabbit Dinner Morsels are suitable for cats of all ages. Keep in mind that feeding freeze-dried raw may not be appropriate for all cats, however, such as cats with some digestive issues or chronic conditions. Be sure to check with your veterinarian.

    Pros
    • Prey-model raw formula
    • No need for rehydrating
    Cons
    • Not appetizing to some cats
    • Not appropriate for some chronic conditions

    divider-cat

    Buyer’s Guide: Selecting the Best Organic Cat Food

    Organic cat food is made from ingredients farmed with no pesticides. To be considered organic, ingredients must be free from pesticides for at least three consecutive years. While that’s the strict definition of organic food, an organic label may contain some organic ingredients, but not a fully organic recipe.

    Here are the benefits of organic cat food:
    • Healthier: While not always true, organic cat food usually contains healthy ingredients without pesticides and other toxins that may cause unwanted side effects or an allergic reaction.
    • No animal byproducts: Many commercial pet foods use parts of the animal that aren’t part of the dressed carcass, such as fat, flesh, blood, hooves, bones, and rennet. It may also mean meat and products from animals that have died in other ways besides slaughter, which could potentially impact your cat’s health. Keep in mind that byproducts are different from a whole-prey model, which includes the appropriate parts of the animal in the appropriate ratios to mimic a wild diet.
    • Balanced weight: Organic foods typically contain healthy ingredients, and not fattening fillers or byproducts. Too much of these ingredients can contribute to obesity in cats, which is already a concern among domesticated animals. Before you put your cat on a diet or limit its intake, try an organic diet to see if it helps with weight control.

    Though these are some of the benefits of organic food, your individual cat’s needs may vary. Be sure to speak with your veterinarian about your cat’s dietary needs and see what they recommend. Also, give your cat time to adjust to a new food before deciding to switch again. It may take as many as three weeks before you see the changes with a new diet, though adverse effects, like vomiting and diarrhea, should be monitored carefully.

    Hepper 360 Cat Feeder, Stainless Steel, Anti-Chew...
    • NO MESS - The 360° tray on this cat food and water bowl set has a raised design to catch and...
    • WHISKER FRIENDLY - Shallow and wide metal containers with flat bottoms ensure your kitty can enjoy...
    • CHEW-SAFE MATERIALS - Kittens and cats love chewing on silicone and soft rubber - but it's a choking...

    High-quality cat food is an important part of fostering a long and healthy life for your cat but the right cat food and water dish will promote good posture, offer whisker relief, and aid in good digestion. The Hepper NomNom Cat Bowl is our favorite bowl since it offers all of the above and is beautifully crafted to meet modern home stylings. The wide tray design catches any food and water spills and the entire setup is dishwasher safe. Learn more about the Hepper NomNom Cat Bowl here.

    At Pet Keen, we’ve admired Hepper for many years and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!

    divider-cat

    Conclusion

    We hope our reviews of the best natural and organic cat foods help you select the best match for your cat. Organic food is an excellent option, and you’ve made a wonderful decision to feed organic food. For the best overall, Smalls Fresh Cat Food offers human-grade fresh food, contains USDA-certified, all-natural ingredients, and is delivered right to your door. For the best value, Purina Beyond Organic Chicken offers organic chicken, USDA-certified ingredients, two different recipes, and is reasonably priced.


    Featured Image Credit: correct pictures, Shutterstock

    Our vets

    Want to talk to a vet online?

    Whether you have concerns about your dog, cat, or other pet, trained vets have the answers!

    Our vets