Pet Keen is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

10 Chewy Online Pet Store Alternatives in 2023: Are They Better?

woman with dog checking out Chewy Affiliate Program

Chewy is one of the most popular online pet supply stores that provides a wide range of supplies for all kinds of pets. However, as extensive as Chewy’s inventory can be, it doesn’t always have what you might be looking for. Items can sometimes be out of stock, or perhaps you Chewy can’t ship to your location.

It’s good to have a couple of backup stores that you can visit so that you lessen the risk of running out of supplies. So, we did some research and have reviews of several reputable and legitimate pet supply stores. Take some time to get to know these stores so that you know exactly where you can go if Chewy doesn’t have what you need.

divider-multipet

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites of 2023

Image Product Details
Winner
PetSmart PetSmart
  • Supplies for all kinds of pets
  • Easy process for purchasing prescriptions
  • Frequent deals and discounts
  • Second place
    PetCo PetCo
  • Extensive inventory of products
  • Offers deals and discounts
  • Has supplies for farm animals
  • The 10 Chewy Online Pet Store Alternatives Compared:

    1. PetSmart

    PetSmart vs Chewy

    PetSmart has a very large online shopping website with supplies for almost all kinds of pets, excluding many exotic pets. It’s a great one-stop shop and is a considerable option for homes with multiple pets. You can also find some brands that aren’t sold on Chewy.

    PetSmart also has a large pharmacy and has a fairly simple and straightforward process for delivering prescription medications to your home.

    Another significant benefit of shopping with PetSmart is the deals and discounts. You can usually find some sort of promotion or deal on PetSmart’s website, so it’s helpful to check back periodically to see if you can take advantage of any deals for your pets.

    We believe that PetSmart is a top-notch Chewy Online Pet Store alternative because of its expansive inventory, easy shipment and delivery process, and specialized care.


    2. BudgetPetCare

    BudgetPetCare vs Chewy

    BudgetPetCare is an online store that offers discounted prices on pet medication and supplements. You can find a good selection of popular pet care brands and items that address all kinds of areas of health including joint care, flea and tick medication, wound care, and behavior control products.

    This website also has many products for homeopathic care for common conditions such as anxiety, digestive upset, and skincare. It’s a great online store that has a good balance of medications and natural products. However, the items are limited to dogs, cats, birds, and horses.

    BudgetPetCare also offers special deals and discounts and free shipping.


    3. Only Natural Pet vs Chewy

    Only Natural Pet vs Chewy

    Only Natural Pet is a premium online pet store that has an extensive inventory of natural pet care products. You can expect to find many dog and cat products that contain all-natural and high-quality ingredients and materials.

    This website only supplies items for dogs and cats and has everything that you need to care for them. It has a lot of options for food and treats, toys, grooming supplies, supplements, and other pet gear.

    You can also find a lot of good deals and discounts offered throughout the year. You can also access free shipping if you meet its price requirement. So, there are a lot of opportunities for savings on natural pet products that usually tend to be expensive.


    4. Petco vs Chewy

    Petco vs Chewy

    Petco is another large pet supply chain that has a wide variety of pet care items. It’s a great option for owners of young puppies and kittens because it carries products for all life stages.

    Like Chewy and PetSmart, Petco has many different kinds of deals and provides discounts for auto-shipping and curbside pickup.

    Along with providing supplies for all kinds of pets, you can also shop for supplies for farm animals. You can find a lot of care products for chickens, horses, and pigs. However, Petco doesn’t carry that many items for exotic pets.

    Petco is a great retailer for all types of shoppers – in person, curb side pickup and delivery.


    5. Allivet vs Chewy

    Allivet vs Chewy

    Allivet offers all kinds of pet care supplies for several different kinds of pets. You can find a decent selection of products for most pets, but you won’t find many items for small pets and reptiles.

    A lot of Allivet’s inventory is focused on health care, so you can find a lot of different medications and remedies for different physical conditions and needs, such as flea and tick medication, supplements, and prescription treatments. Also, many prices of medications are comparably low.

    Allivet offers free shipping if you spend a certain amount, and there’s also a live chat option on the website where you can speak with a specialist if you have any questions about an item.


    6. Pet Supplies Plus vs Chewy

    Pet Supplies Plus vs Chewy

    Pet Supplies Plus offers a lot of different pet supplies for a wide variety of pets. It also has a free membership program that provides special discounts on all kinds of items. You can also accumulate points that you can use for more discounts on items.

    This pet supply company does offer curbside pickup and delivery, but it only ships to addresses within 7 miles of a physical store location. So, if you don’t live near a Pet Supplies Plus store, you won’t be able to have items delivered to your home.


    7. EntirelyPets vs Chewy

    EntirelyPets vs Chewy

    EntirelyPets has an inventory of all kinds of pet care supplies, but it focuses mostly on caring for dogs and cats. You can find a lot of different types of medications and supplements for pets as well as a good mix of premium and affordable food, treats, and toys.

    This pet supply store has a membership program where you can accumulate points to earn discounts on future purchases. It also has a referral incentive, so you can earn even more rewards if a friend creates an account or makes a purchase.

    Along with membership benefits, EntirelyPets regularly offers deals and special sales, so it doesn’t hurt to keep an eye out on this website.


    8. PetCareRX vs Chewy

    PetCareRX vs Chewy

    PetCareRx has a good selection of medication and supplements for dogs and cats, and you can also find a lot of other different items such as food, furniture, and toys. A lot of the medications have comparable prices, and for additional savings, you can check out the daily coupons and deals on the site. The process of purchasing prescription medication is also relatively simple and easy.

    If you find that you really enjoy shopping with PetCareRx, you can sign up for a paid membership that offers up to 40% off items, unlimited free shipping, and other savings opportunities.

    This is an excellent Chewy alternative if you are looking to get a wide variety of health related products.


    9. Amazon

    Chewy alternative
    Left Image Credit: Rita_Kochmarjova, Shutterstock

    Amazon has a very large selection of pet supply products for all kinds of pets, and you can also often find items for exotic pets. It’s also easy to access and find pet products because Amazon has a designated pet supply department.

    Amazon also offers daily deals, and you can usually save on pet products or get discounted prices on some overstocked items. It has a decent selection of both affordable and premium pet food brands, but it’s not as extensive as other pet supply stores, such as PetSmart and Petco.

    You also can’t purchase prescription pet medication through Amazon, but you can find basic health care and grooming products, including some flea and tick medication.

    There is nothing more convenient than free shipping and speedy delivery. For everything outside of your pets meds and possibly specialty items, Amazon is a great place to check out!


    10. The Animal Rescue vs Chewy

    The Animal Rescue vs Chewy

    If you want to shop for a good cause, make sure to visit The Animal Rescue’s pet supply section. Although the selection is small, part of the money made on purchases will go towards supporting a charity.

    The Animal Rescue has a unique selection of basic pet care items for dogs and cats but doesn’t have food options. Since it’s a site that supports charity work, it doesn’t really put discounts on items. However, you can find a few sales every once in a while.

    divider-multipet

    How To Avoid Fraudulent Pet Supply Websites

    During the pandemic, the appearance of fake pet supply stores and scams rose significantly. The Better Business Bureau (BBB) stated that 25% of scam reports they received were related to pet scams.

    Scam websites can steal credit card information or steal money by never sending any of the products that they advertise. Therefore, it’s important to be vigilant and only buy products from legitimate websites.

    It’s best to purchase items from reputable websites, such as the ones listed in this article. If you see any ads on social media with offers that seem too good to be true, they’re most likely scams.

    Also, make sure that the web address doesn’t appear suspicious. They should be secured by beginning with “https://” and have a reasonable spelling that reflects the company’s name, such as “petco.com” or “chewy.com.”

    Another safety measure you can take is to verify the retailer’s contact information. Make sure that the company’s address exists and that the phone number works. Websites with an “About Us” page and extensive information on the brand’s history usually means that the website belongs to a legitimate retailer.

    divider-multiprint

    Conclusion

    Based on our reviews, PetSmart is our favorite overall Chewy online pet store alternative. It has many similar features as Chewy and also carries some products that you can’t find on Chewy. We also love Petco for similar reasons as PetSmart, and the option to shop online, in-store, or place an order for a quick curb-side pickup.

    BudgetPetCare is another one we stand behind because it provides prescription medications for several different kinds of pets, and the shipment and delivery process is relatively simple and quick. Finally, Amazon is high on our list of recommendations for its ease and convenience.

    See also: 5 Largest Online Pet Retailers in 2022: Reviews & Top Picks


    Featured Image Credit: nakaridore, Freepik

    Our vets

    Want to talk to a vet online?

    Whether you have concerns about your dog, cat, or other pet, trained vets have the answers!

    Our vets