Pet Keen is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Hartz Cat Toys Review 2023: Pros, Cons & Verdict

Review Summary

Our Final Verdict

We give Hartz Cat Toys a rating of 4 out of 5 stars.

Introduction

Hartz has been making pet toys for over 90 years and is well known in the pet industry. They make both dog and cat products that are available in numerous stores throughout the country and online, with a wide variety of toys, chews, treats, and even flea and tick products. Many of their toys are produced in China, and they only use trusted vendors, many of which have worked with Hartz for several years.

In this article, we’ll focus on Hartz cat toys. Whether your cat loves to interact with you or prefers to play alone, you can find a cat toy that will appease your kitty. Let’s explore this company together to see if Hartz cat toys are suitable for you and your cat.

divider-cat

At a Glance: The Best Hartz Cat Toys

Image Product Details
Our Favorite
Winner
Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack
  • Inexpensive
  • Includes a catnip-stuffed fish
  • Comes with 13 different toys
  • Second place
    Hartz Cattraction Silver Vine Catnip Hartz Cattraction Silver Vine Catnip
  • Soft and plush material
  • Mice have bells to entice play
  • Infused with both Silver Vine and catnip
  • Third place
    Hartz Peek & Play Pop-Up Cat Tent Toy Hartz Peek & Play Pop-Up Cat Tent Toy
  • Peepholes for hide-n-seek
  • Offers different stimulations
  • Contains a detachable scratchpad
  • Hartz Just For Cats Super Hunters Hartz Just For Cats Super Hunters
  • Catnip filled plush toys
  • Suitable for all life stages
  • Variety pack comes with 13 toys
  • Hartz Cattraction Silver Vine & Catnip Gator Hartz Cattraction Silver Vine & Catnip Gator
  • Withstand rigorous play
  • Plush gator promotes of plenty of exercise
  • Satisfies cats natural instincts to hunt and play
  • divider-cat

    Hartz Cat Toys Reviewed

    Where Are Hartz Cat Toys Produced?

    Hartz produces most of its toys in China. The company uses a quality-control team to inspect each toy to ensure all toys meet quality standards. Hartz has been in business for more than 90 years and uses only trusted vendors to make top-quality toys for both dogs and cats. Many of the vendors have worked with Hartz for several years with the goal of making safe and quality toys and products.

    Which Type of Cat Is Hartz Toys Best Suited For?

    Hartz cat toys are suited for any cat that loves to play. Hartz makes a variety of interactive toys for sassy cats, as well as interactive toys for loner cats that would rather play by themselves. Toys are essential for your cat’s overall well-being and provide many benefits, such as exploration, interaction, stimulation, and satisfying your cat’s natural prey drive.

    divider-cat

    Discussion of the Primary Materials (Good and Bad)

    As with any toy, cat parents want assurance that the materials used to make the toy are safe for their beloved feline. Let’s now break down a few materials they use to give you a better understanding of what they are.

    Silver Vine

    Silver Vine is an alternative to catnip that can be found in many of their cat toys. Part of the Kiwi family, it is non-toxic, non-addicting, and 100% natural. Silver Vine has been proven to attract cats in Japan and Asia, and the vine grows naturally in the eastern mountains of Asia. Hartz infuses both Silver Vine and catnip for a combination that attracts cats up to 91% compared to just 68% with catnip alone.

    Phthalates

    Phthalates are esters of phthalic acid used as plasticizers, or in other words, it’s a chemical that makes plastic more flexible. Hartz claims that they comply with the government safety guidelines of phthalates content, and all toys undergo testing at their facilities. The company does not, however, disclose if any phthalates are in the toys.

    divider-cat

    A Quick Look at Hartz Cat Toys

    Pros
    • Many come with a combo of silver vine and catnip
    • Affordable
    • Variety to choose from
    Cons
    • Some toys do not hold up long
    • Some toys smell of chemicals

    Recall History

    To date, Hartz has not had any recalls regarding their cat toys, but the company has seen its fair share of complaints from customers who took their concerns to the Better Business Bureau (BBB). Hartz has recalls in other areas of their products, such as flea and tick shampoo, treats, and chews for dogs. These particular recalls occurred in 2013.

    Well-designed toys will keep your cat happy and engaged. For a sturdy, fun toy that will look nice in your living room, we recommend Hepper's Catnip Stick Toy! These toys are designed to look like prey and double-bagged to stand up to your cat's sharpest claws and teeth. Plus, they're filled with organic catnip and handmade in the USA.Hepper Catnip StixAt Pet Keen, we've admired Hepper for many years, and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!

    divider-cat

    Reviews of the 3 Best Hartz Cat Toys

    Let’s now take a more in-depth look at 3 cat toys from Hartz.

    1. Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack

    Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack, 13-Count

    The Hartz Just For Cats Toy Variety Pack has plenty of toys to keep your cat busy and engaged in playtime. This variety pack includes pom-poms, balls, mice, a catnip-stuffed fish, and a wand baton. The toys are made from plastic, polyester, and synthetic fabric. Some of the balls contain a bell inside, which naturally keeps your cat’s attention. This variety pack is perfect for both the reclusive, shy cat to the playful and entertaining cat. The wand allows for interaction between you and your beloved feline, and the pack itself is inexpensive.

    Some consumers state that the balls have a chemical smell, and they may crack, which can cause the ball to get caught in the teeth. However, for the price, this variety pack offers 13 different toys that will hopefully be a hit with your kitty.

    Pros
    • Comes with 13 different toys
    • Includes a catnip-stuffed fish
    • Inexpensive
    Cons
    • Balls have a chemical smell
    • Balls may crack

    2. Hartz Cattraction Silver Vine Catnip

    Hartz Cattraction Silver Vine Catnip, 2-Count

    The Hartz Cattraction Silver Vine Catnip comes with two plush mice infused with Silver Vine and catnip for more engaging play and interest. The mice have bells that jingle when your cat plays with them, and they come in pastel colors. They are soft and work well to stimulate your kitty.

    A common complaint with these mice is that cats are not attracted to them and have no interest in playing. Every cat is different, and there is no way to tell if your kitty will enjoy these or not. Nonetheless, for the price, they are worth trying.

    Pros
    • Infused with both Silver Vine and catnip
    • Mice have bells to entice play
    • Soft and plush material
    Cons
    • Some cats have no interest in this toy

    3. Hartz Just for Cats Peek & Play Pop-Up Cat Tent

    Hartz Just for Cats Peek & Play Pop-Up Cat Tent Toy

    The Hartz Just For Cats Peek & Play Pop-Up Cat Tent is an excellent toy for your kitty to hide, lounge, nap, or scratch on. This tent is a one-step easy assembly that will provide your cat with different stimulations. It comes with two dangling swat toys for swatting and batting, a detachable scratch pad, and three peepholes that are fun for multiple cats.

    The tent measures 24″L X 14.5″W X 8.5″H. Some consumers claim the tent is not big enough for cats but rather more fitting for kittens. Supervising your cat while playing with this toy is advised to ensure the head doesn’t get stuck in one of the peepholes. It will also slide around on a hard floor, which could add to the fun but is a nuisance to some cat owners who purchased this toy.

    Pros
    • Offers different stimulations
    • Comes with two batting balls
    • Contains a detachable scratchpad
    • Peepholes for hide-n-seek
    • Easy assembly
    Cons
    • May not be big enough for adult cats
    • Tent slides on hard surfaces

    divider-cat

    What Other Users Are Saying

    As pet owners, it’s always beneficial to read consumer reviews before buying any product. By reading reviews, you can get a sense of the product and how well it holds up. To get an idea, you can read reviews from Amazon regarding the cat tent toy and others here.

    divider-cat

    Conclusion

    Hartz has a wide variety of cat toys to choose from. Many toys include a combination of Silver Vine and catnip for more attraction, and their toys provide the mental stimulation cats require to be healthy and happy. Always supervise your cat while playing with any toy, as no toy is completely indestructible. All Hartz toys are thoroughly inspected for safety, and they are affordable.

    Our vets

    Want to talk to a vet online?

    Whether you have concerns about your dog, cat, or other pet, trained vets have the answers!

    Our vets