Pet Keen is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Home > Insurance > Pumpkin vs. ASPCA Pet Insurance Comparison 2024: Pros, Cons & Verdict

Pumpkin vs. ASPCA Pet Insurance Comparison 2024: Pros, Cons & Verdict

If you’re looking to insure your dog or cat, two pet insurance companies that have comprehensive plans with competitive rates are Pumpkin pet insurance and the ASPCA. But how do you decide which one is right for you?

There are pros and cons to both companies, and the right insurance plan for your pet comes down to what exactly you’re looking for.

To help you understand your options so you can decide, here, we cover the reimbursement rates, deductibles, coverage limits, and more for both Pumpkin and ASPCA pet insurance plans.

Best Dental Coverage
Our rating: 4.5 / 5
Best Coverage Limit
Our rating: 4.5 / 5
Company Name Pumpkin ASPCA
Pets Covered Dogs and cats Dogs and cats
Types of Plans Insurance coverage and wellness plans Insurance coverage
Deductibles $100, $250, or $500 $100, $250, or $500
Reimbursement 90% 70, 80, or 90%
Additional Perks Optional wellness package, multi-pet discounts Extremely customizable plans, multi-pet discounts, and preventative packages

Brief Overview of Pumpkin

Pumpkin Pet Insurance

Pros
  • Comprehensive coverage
  • Great coverage
  • Option for an unlimited annual limit
  • Easy to use
  • Optional wellness package
Cons
  • Limited coverage options
  • Expensive plans

While Pumpkin pet insurance might not be a household name, it provides a top-notch pet insurance plan to every pet that applies. It offers 90% reimbursement rates and maximum annual reimbursements start at $10,000.

Even better, you can up the maximum annual reimbursement to be as high as you want, and it covers many events, including dental problems, behavioral issues, and even alternative therapies, so you can whatever you feel is right for your pet without worrying about the price.

Finally, while Pumpkin is a great pet insurance brand, it also has a wellness package, to help ensure that you can catch any problems early on. It wants you to keep up with your pet’s annual checks, so it covers 100% of the costs associated with these visits, including tests.


Brief Overview of ASPCA

ASPCA Pet Health Insurance

Pros
  • Easy-to-use plans
  • Highly adjustable coverage limits
  • Affordable options
  • Get the amount of coverage that you can afford
Cons
  • Low insurance plans don’t cover much
  • Capped maximum annual limits

The ASPCA is a top name in the pet industry, and it has a pet insurance policy with tons of flexibility. Not only do you get to pick your own deductible, but you also get to pick reimbursement and coverage levels.

This extra flexibility enables you to get a pet insurance plan with a premium that fits into your budget, instead of skipping pet insurance altogether because you can’t afford it.

ASPCA also makes using your pet insurance easy because you can submit claims online, by mail, or even by fax, and it will send direct deposit reimbursements right into your bank account. Even better, you can use whatever vet you like, as the ASPCA doesn’t limit coverage to select facilities.


Other Top Rated Pet Insurance Companies

Best Overall
Our rating: 4.6 / 5
Most Customizable
Our rating: 4.4 / 5
Best for Wellness Plans
Our rating: 4.0 / 5

Pumpkin vs ASPCA: Plans Available

As we’ve stated, no two pet insurance companies are the same. They all have their own protocols and procedures, as well as their own plans and what they cover. Let’s take a look below to compare the two regarding the plans available within each company.

Company Sample Monthly Cost For Dogs Sample Monthly Cost For Cats Learn More
Pumpkin $57.69 $26.92 Click to Get Quote
ASPCA $21.40 $12.18 Click to Get Quote

Pumpkin

Pumpkin offers one pet insurance plan and then enables you to customize the annual limit and deductible. Pumpkin plans cover about anything that you can think of, including hereditary problems, behavioral issues, alternative treatments, dental problems, and much more.

ASPCA

The ASPCA offers one pet insurance plan, but you can customize the reimbursement rate, annual deductible, and annual limit to get a plan that you can afford. Its plans cover dental issues, behavioral issues, illnesses, accidents, and even heredity conditions.

Find The Best Pet Insurance Companies in 2024


Pumpkin vs. ASPCA: Reimbursements and Deductibles

Pumpkin

% of Medical Expenses
  • 90%
Annual Deductible Options
  • $100
  • $250
  • $500
Maximum Coverage Options
  • $7,000
  • $10,000
  • Unlimited

Pumpkin has a straightforward system. Every plan comes with a 90% reimbursement rate on all treatments. Moreover, the maximum annual reimbursement starts between $7,000 and $10,000, but you can raise it to an unlimited annual limit if you want. Finally, there are three deductible options to choose from: $100, $250, or $500.

ASPCA

% of Medical Expenses
  • 70%
  • 90%
Annual Deductible Options
  • $100
  • $250
  • $500
Maximum Coverage Options
  • $3,000
  • $15,000

The ASPCA offers extremely customizable insurance plans. Annual coverage limits range from $3,000 to $15,000, and reimbursement rates range from 70% to 90%. Finally, it has the same deductible range as Pumpkin at $100, $250, or $500.


Pumpkin vs. ASPCA: Additional Perks

Pumpkin

The most notable perk that Pumpkin offers outside of its insurance reimbursements is its wellness package. This covers vaccines, wellness exams, and even fecal tests to ensure that your pet doesn’t have any underlying conditions. Even better, this add-on has a 100% reimbursement rate.

ASPCA

One of the top perks of the ASPCA is how easy it is to use its plans. You can go to any vet that you want, and you can file claims in various ways. It also sends money to you via direct deposit, making getting your reimbursement extremely fast and easy!


Company Verdict: Which One Has the Edge?

Customer Service 📞

Edge: ASPCA

It’s a tough decision here, but due to the comprehensive way that the ASPCA takes claims, it gets the slight edge here. While its online claim submission is easy, if you’re not technologically inclined, it also takes claims through the mail or even fax. It looks out for all of its customers this way.

Price of Plans💲

Edge: ASPCA

When you compare the prices of the ASPCA and Pumpkin plans, they’re practically identical. However, since the ASPCA offers lower-end plans while Pumpkin makes you go with the premium option, the ASPCA has an advantage in the price category. But they’re similarly priced for similar coverage.

Areas of Coverage 🌐

Edge: Pumpkin

While both the ASPCA and Pumpkin cover multiple issues, Pumpkin covers alternative therapies, giving them a slight edge here. Both companies cover dental illnesses, behavioral issues, illnesses, and accidents, though.

Both plans do not cover any pre-existing conditions that your pet has. Still, no matter what plan you go with, you’re getting great coverage regardless of what happens with your pet.

Perks📱

Edge: Pumpkin

Neither pet insurance company has many perks, but with its optional wellness package, Pumpkin gets the slight edge here. It covers preventative care, so you can catch issues early before they have a chance to progress to more severe illnesses.

Find The Best Pet Insurance Companies in 2024


Conclusion

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Logo aspca pet insurrance logo
Pumpkin ASPCA
Our Rating
Our Rating:
Our Rating:
Chronic Conditions
Chronic Conditions:
Chronic Conditions:
Wellness Options
Wellness Options:
Wellness Options:
Multi-Pet Discount
Multi-Pet Discount:
Multi-Pet Discount:
Dental Options
Dental Options:
Dental Options:

There’s no wrong choice between Pumpkin and the ASPCA pet insurance plans. If you’re on a tight budget, the ASPCA pet insurance plan can get your pet covered, even if it’s not the best possible plan out there.

However, if you’re going for a top-notch plan, go with Pumpkin. Not only does it offer one of the most comprehensive insurance plans out there, but it also has a wellness package to help you catch problems early, reducing the chances that you’ll need to use your pet insurance in the first place.

  • Pet Keen acknowledges that it is not licensed as an insurance agent, and therefore will not offer any advice regarding insurance, nor recommend a particular coverage, policy, or insurance company.
Our vets

Want to talk to a vet online?

Whether you have concerns about your dog, cat, or other pet, trained vets have the answers!

Our vets