The Shetland Sheepdog is nicknamed the Sheltie and is a herder from the Shetland Islands of Scotland. They used to stand guard for the farmers and prevent birds and sheep from launching into the farmers’ gardens. The dogs, although small, are high energy and fast but highly obedient. They are champions in sports performance and easy to train. Their over−protective and affectionate nature makes them lovable family pets, and they have the excellent qualities of a watchdog.
The Australian Shepherd, also known as an Aussie, is an active dog bred and herding dog of choice for cowboys. They have a strong work drive and are intelligent and loyal. They are medium-sized, muscular dogs with agile builds. With their herding instincts and eagerness to work, they enjoy playing frisbee and chasing moving objects. With early socialization, they are great family dogs that will love being companions to children and other pets.
At a Glance
Shetland Sheepdog Overview
Shelties look like a smaller version of a Collie. They are small yet strong and agile, with a shoulder height of 13 to 16 inches. Their outer coat is long and straight with a dense and wooly undercoat. The Sheltie has a lush mane, as well as frills and feathering on the legs and tail, and their high-set ears are small, with the tips slightly forward. Shelties are available in black, blue merle, and sable with white markings.
Personality / Character
The personality of a Sheltie varies from outgoing and energetic to shy and calm. When it comes to their owners and families, they can be overprotective but loving, affectionate, and loyal.
They may be timid and reserved with strangers, but with time, strangers can become friends. They are sensitive dogs that are highly in tune with the mood of their owners. With their vocal skills, reservation to strangers, and need to protect their family, they are excellent watchdogs.
Shelties need early socialization, and puppy classes are recommended to assist your pet in growing into a well-rounded dog. They have high energy, are intelligent, and are eager to please, making them highly trainable. They have a reputation for being stars in the field of agility.
Because Shelties are herding dogs, they enjoy herding smaller animals and even children. While this may seem cute, it should not be encouraged because it can lead to biting.
Health & Care
Shelties are typically healthy dogs with a life expectancy of up to 15 years but are prone to a few health concerns, like most dog breeds. This does not mean they will inherit the disease, but you should know what is possible.
Health concerns in a Sheltie may include Patella luxation, hypothyroidism, Von Willebrand’s disease, canine hip dysplasia, collie eye anomaly, allergies, and dermatomyositis. One merle should not be bred with another merle because a homozygous merle trait is dangerous and can be fatal.
A high-quality protein source should be near the top of the ingredients list on your dog’s food. You can also feed your Sheltie raw meat bones, which should equal 15−20% of their body weight per week, and you will most likely need to supplement certain nutrients to ensure they are getting a well-balanced diet.
Shelties have a thick double coat that sheds a great deal. The outer fur is long and thick, and the undercoat is dense and fluffy. Its coat will need to be brushed every other day, and during shedding, it will require more regular brushing to remove the loose hair. A Sheltie will also need to be checked regularly for matting, especially behind the ears, the elbows, and under the tail.
Nails should be trimmed regularly; you can usually tell they need clipping when you can hear them tapping on the floor, and it’s not recommended to shave their coat as it protects from sunburn, heat, and the cold.
Shelties are happy to stay at home alone if they get their dose of attention when their owners return from work. Apartment living is also suitable for a Sheltie since they are typically inactive when indoors, as long as they get a daily walk.
They are very active dogs that will need a routine of mental and physical exercise; if they are not exercised regularly, they may become anxious and nervous. Shelties will thrive in a home where they are given lots of attention, playtime, training, and love, which will be returned unconditionally.
Australian Shepherd Overview
Aussies are medium-sized dogs with muscular, agile builds and penetrating eye gaze. They reach a shoulder height of 18−23 inches, and the males are typically taller and heavier than the females. Their coat is medium length and beautifully lush. They have feathers on the backs of their legs, a thick mane around their neck, and a naturally short tail, but tails that are longer than 4 inches are sometimes docked. Their coat color ranges from blue or red merle to red or black tricolor with white or tan markings.
Personality / Character
Aussies are highly active yet easygoing and love to play with kids and other pets. They have a strong work drive and are highly intelligent and eager to please, making them easy to train.
They can be very well-mannered dogs and are loyal and attentive to their owners. As family dogs, they are very protective and will be sure to let you know if a stranger is approaching. They are excellent family dogs if they have been socialized early.
Aussies are energetic, athletic dogs that need to exercise regularly. The breed requires regular exercise and mental stimulation and may develop destructive behaviors if they do not have an outlet for their energy. Their attachment to their favorite humans can sometimes lead to separation anxiety.
The Australian Shepherd requires early socialization and obedience training, and because they are smart, they are typically easy to train. They can be well-behaved dogs with proper training, socialization, and regular exercise. They thrive on a farm or big yard where they can run around, and they love to join on family hikes and walks.
Health & Care
Australian Shepherds have a life expectancy of 12−15 years and are generally healthy dogs. They are, however, predisposed to a few health issues that are more common in the breed. Hip and elbow dysplasia, progressive retinal atrophy, ocular conditions, epilepsy, deafness, and various cancers are all common health conditions.
Australian Shepherds should be fed a high-quality diet and always have access to fresh water. Active Aussies may require a higher protein/ fat diet to meet their nutritional requirements.
Because Australian Shepherds shed moderately, regular brushing can help to reduce shedding during their shedding season. Weekly brushing sessions will keep their coat in good condition and prevent the development of matted fur, which can cause inflammation and infection of the underlying skin. Shaving is not usually advised because their double coat protects them from heat and cold.
An Aussie’s ears should be checked to remove foreign matter and wax buildup, and their teeth should be brushed regularly. Because Australian Shepherds are predisposed to certain eye issues, it is a good habit to monitor for excessive discharge or changes in appearance.
Aussies need to be kept busy and are best suited to country living. Alternatively, a large fenced-in yard will suffice as long as the owner spends a significant amount of time with them. They will require a family devoted to regular exercise and playtime because if they are left alone, they become destructive.
Training and socialization will also be essential components of the Australian Shepherd’s mental and physical development. They thrive on advanced training exercises and fun dog sports, which can be a big investment in time and money.
Which Breed Is Right for You?
Both Shelties and Aussies make great family pets if they are socialized early and given the physical and mental stimulation they need. Both breeds require regular grooming and high-quality, well-balanced diets to suit their active lifestyles. They are both loveable and affectionate dogs that are protective of their owners and will make excellent watchdogs. They have herding instincts and are prone to nipping and herding moving objects like children and animals.
The most notable difference we can make to help decide which breed is best for you is that an Australian Shepherd needs more intense exercise and mental stimulation. They are also better suited to country living where they can freely run around, whereas a Sheltie can happily live in the city if it gets a daily walk or runs.
If you live in the country, are home often, enjoy the outdoor lifestyle, have extra time, and are looking for an active companion, then an Australian Shepherd is the right breed for you. If you are a working person looking for a companion that can enjoy a daily walk but is happy to be home alone, then a Shetland Sheepdog is the ideal match.
Featured Image Credit: Top – Shetland Sheepdog (Lisjatina, Shutterstock) Bottom – Australian Shepherd (EileenKumpf, shutterstock)