Many inexperienced goldfish owners think of their fish as pets that they need to simply feed once or twice a day and that’s it. But, in reality, goldfish require much more care and need to be fed the right foods and treats to keep them happy and healthy in their little goldfish world.
If you’ve recently purchased your first goldfish, you’re probably a little overwhelmed by the wide variety of choices for treats to give them.
In this buying guide, we’ll give you a few of what we consider to be the best goldfish treats on the market in 2021 along with reviews to help you make the right choice for your goldfish friend.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites
|Best Overall||Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm Treat||
|Best Value||Tetra Baby Shrimp||
|Premium Choice||Omega One Freeze-Dried Worms||
|Aqueon Goldfish Food Granules||
|Tetra River Shrimp||
The 5 Best Treats Your Goldfish Will Go Crazy for – Reviews & Top Picks 2022
1. Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm Treat – Best Overall
|Brand:||Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm Treat|
|Item Form:||Live food|
|Breed Recommendation:||All goldfish|
In our opinion, the best overall goldfish treat to feed your goldfish is Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm Treats. Not only is this a fun and healthy treat for your goldfish, but this farm treat is also a way to keep your fish engaged. Since the worm farm contains live worms, your fish will need to catch them to eat them.
This treat can be used for more than treating your goldfish, however. In fact, the treats have been used as fish bait and given to birds and reptiles as treats as well. If you want to keep these treats on hand all the time, then take a package of Uncle Jim’s and start your own worm farm with it. It’s important to note since this is live food, there are some restrictions, and these aren’t sold in Hawaii.
On the healthy side of things, these worms are chock full of protein, which makes them a great treat for your young goldfish, or if you’re breeding fish also. However, if you have young fish, it might be best to cut these red worms into bite-sized portions for their safety.
2. Tetra Baby Shrimp – Best Value
|Breed Recommendation:||Small breeds|
The best goldfish treat for the money, in our opinion, is Tetra Baby Shrimp. You won’t find any fillers or ingredients that aren’t good for your goldfish in this treat. Instead, it features one signal ingredient, and that’s shrimp. This treat breaks down to having 45% protein, 6% fiber, and 6% fat, making it super healthy for your pet.
Another great thing about this treat is that you can give it to freshwater and saltwater fish, meaning if you have goldfish in one tank and other fish in another tank, this treat can be used for both, making it the best treat on our list for value.
While it can be a great source of treats for breeding fish, is excellent for fish that enjoy floating food, and is recommended for small breeds of fish at every lift stage, it’s not recommended as a portion of food you feed them daily.
3. Omega One Freeze-Dried Worms – Premium Choice
|Item Form:||Freeze-dried blood worms|
|Breed Recommendation:||Goldfish, cichlids, betta, freshwater, etc.|
If you’re looking for a goldfish treat that is extremely high in protein, then the Omega One Freeze-Dried Worms fit the bill. The worms are freeze-dried to lock in flavor and to keep out any bacteria or parasites that might be lurking, ready to make your fish sick.
This treat is also good for other freshwater fish and is perfect if you’re a breeder. It’s 5% fiber, 3% fat, and 55% protein, which makes it great for helping to maintain the brilliant colors of your fish. However, this food is not recommended for daily feeding, so only give it as a treat one to three times a week. You can choose from two canister sizes for the best value, and the freeze-dried texture makes this the perfect treat for fish who like floating or sinking foods.
Related Read: What Do Goldfish Eat? Different Types of Foods to Offer
Many goldfish die as a result of improper feeding, diet, and/or portion sizes – which can be easily prevented by proper education.
That's why we recommend the best-selling book, The Truth About Goldfish, which covers everything about goldfish nutrition, tank maintenance, illnesses & more! Check it out on Amazon today.
4. Aqueon Goldfish Food Granules
|Breed Recommendation:||All sizes|
If you’re looking for a goldfish treat that’s a food as well, then Aqueon Goldfish Food Granules can help with that. All the ingredients and nutrients are natural, meaning it’s good for your fish, and the food is formulated so that it creates less waste while drawing your fish to eat it, which is healthier for them.
This item also works with your water instead of against it, so the water doesn’t cloud as your fish eats. So, if you’re looking for goldfish food that your fish will consider a treat, then this is the one.
5. Tetra River Shrimp
|Breed Recommendation:||Medium-sized fish|
Last but not least on our list of yummy treats for your goldfish is Omega One Freeze-Dried Worms. This protein-rich fish food is designed for medium-sized breeds of fish. Since river shrimp is the only ingredient in this treat, you can be sure it’s healthy for your fish and doesn’t have a ton of fillers added.
It’s an inexpensive treat to give your goldfish and contains over 60% protein, making it a protein-rich food that they’ll enjoy. Since there is a high percentage of carotene in these flakes, it’s a great way to improve your fish’s color, on top of being a great way to feed your fish roughage.
While it is an excellent idea for an occasional treat, it’s for medium-sized fish. So, if you have a small breed of fish, make sure to break the shrimp so it’s easier for them to eat and digest since it’s easy to break apart.
You might also be interested in: 10 Best Goldfish Foods – Reviews & Top Picks
Now that you know the top five goldfish treats on the market for 2021, it’s time to go into a little bit about what to look for and the types of goldfish treats there are available for your pet fish.
How to Choose the Right Goldfish Treats
There are four main things you should look for when choosing the healthiest goldfish treats for your pet: the ingredients, where the food was sourced, whether it’s a sinking or floating treat, and the nutritional content. We’ll talk a little about each of these below.
While this isn’t as important for flakes or granules, if you’re offering your goldfish live treats, then it’s best to know where they were sourced. For example, you need to know where any insects or worms come from before you get them for your fish because you don’t know what type of pesticides could have been used on them. It’s also important to make sure the food is parasite and bacteria-free.
Of course, you want only the top ingredients available in the food you offer your pet fish. That’s why it’s best to look for treats that have a single ingredient instead of fillers and multiple things that you don’t know or can’t even begin to pronounce. Besides that, having a lot of fillers in your treats will muddy the water in your tank, which isn’t good for your fish either.
Sink or Float?
The choice between sinking treats and floating treats has quite a bit to do with the type of goldfish you have. For example, some goldfish need food that sinks because floating food can give them air bubbles in their tummy. Also, some fish just prefer to float to the top to eat treats, while others are shyer and prefer to stay hidden and eat treats from the bottom of the tank.
Just as with other pets, fish need different nutritional content at different ages. Believe it or not, fish can become overweight, which can lead to health problems. So, making sure to feed them treats that are low in fat is key to ensuring they stay at a healthy weight and are healthy overall as well. In addition, goldfish need treats that are high in protein, especially when they’re young or breeding.
It’s also important not to go overboard on the treats you feed your goldfish; they are treats for a reason, to be doled out in moderation.
What Are the Different Types of Goldfish Treats?
While we’ve covered the goldfish treats we think are the best above, there are a few different types of goldfish treats for you to choose from. In this next section, we’ll discuss a little about each type, so you’re prepared to buy only the best for your pet goldfish.
Live foods are fun and natural for your goldfish. Live food not only gives them the nutrition they need, but it also gives them something to actively go after as well. However, as previously stated, it’s essential to make sure you know where the food is sourced from to avoid poisons and bacteria.
Frozen treats are also an excellent option for those who are squeamish about feeding live treats to their fish. It’s possible to give these treats to your fish in the block of ice they come in, so they can get to them themselves, or some fish might prefer you to thaw the treats first; the choice is yours. Again, make sure to buy local, so you know the quality of the food and are able to get it home before it begins to thaw as well.
While frozen treats are excellent sources of protein for your fish, so are freeze-dried treats. These treats are dehydrated and then plump up when put in the water as they start to rehydrate. These treats are great because they have all the nutritional value of live food. Still, you don’t have to worry about chemicals, bacteria, or other problems associated with live food that isn’t properly sourced.
Last on our list is processed treats. While these treats do have a longer shelf life than the options above, they’re also not great when it comes to providing nutritional value to your fish. The calories from these types of treats are empty calories, and they provide very little nutrition.
These are just a few of the types of treats and a few tips you should follow when finding the right yummy treats to keep your goldfish both happy and healthy. Of course, which ones you choose are up to you; just make sure they’re the right choice for your pet fish.
Related Read: 41 Facts About Goldfish That Will Surprise You
This concludes our reviews on the five yummiest treats for your goldfish. The best overall, in our opinion, is Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm Treat because it provides live food with something to keep your goldfish active while they eat. Our top choice for the best value is Tetra Baby Shrimp because it’s so cost-effective and can be used for both freshwater and saltwater fish, meaning you spend less but get more.
Third, but not least, is our pick for premium choice, Omega One’s Freeze-dried worms. With 55% protein content, and the ability to order in two different sizes, it’s no wonder this goldfish treat made it into the top three in our list. If you’re new to keeping goldfish or just overwhelmed with the options for goldfish treats, these reviews should help you make an educated final decision.