Pet Keen is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

6 Best Fresh Cat Food Delivery Services in Canada in 2023 — Reviews & Top Picks

cat ordering food online

More pet parents are starting to reject highly processed and manufactured pet food for high-quality fresh food. There are several fresh food companies that produce cat food with high-quality proteins and carbohydrates and without artificial ingredients. Not only can you ensure that your beloved cat is eating top-quality food, but you also don’t have to worry about constantly needing to remember to purchase it at the store — these companies all use subscription and delivery services.

But finding the right food for your cat, particularly in Canada, can be tricky because many of these foods are typically based out of the U.S. We want our food to arrive fresh! Here are reviews of six companies that make and deliver fresh cat food, so you just need to click, read, and order!

divider-cat

A Glance at Our Favorites in 2023

Image Product Details
Best Overall
Winner
Tom & Sawyer Pet Food Tom & Sawyer Pet Food
  • Handmade food from Toronto
  • Available in three flavours lightly cooked
  • Build a meal plan after answering questions about your cat
  • Best Value
    Second place
    TLC Pet Food TLC Pet Food
  • Less expensive than other, comparable high-quality cat foods
  • Made with high-quality, fresh ingredients
  • Includes cranberries for urinary tract health
  • Premium Choice
    Third place
    Open Farm Cat Food Open Farm Cat Food
  • Offers four flavours of dry food and six flavours of wet wood
  • Animal sources are gathered sustainably and humanely   
  • No GMOs, hormones, antibiotics, or artificial ingredients
  • Smack Pet Food Smack Pet Food
  • Three recipes of raw, dehydrated food
  • Free-range chicken and wild-caught salmon
  • Uses fresh ingredients that are dehydrated using gentle, low-temperature air-drying
  • PetzLove Pet Food PetzLove Pet Food
  • Available in two sizes and two flavours
  • Ingredients locally sourced in Canada
  • Good for all life stages
  • The 6 Best Fresh Cat Food Delivery Services in Canada

    1. Tom & Sawyer Pet Food — Best Overall

    Tom and Sawyer Logo

     

    Recipes: Tuna and sweet potato, chicken and cheese, or beef and carrots
    Food type: Minced
    Standout feature: Made by hand with only natural ingredients

    Tom & Sawyer Pet Food is based in Toronto. You have the option for delivery, or if you’re in the Toronto area, you can pop into the kitchen and purchase the food or go to one of the retailers across Canada to try it out first. Each meal is 454 grams and is available in three flavours — tuna and sweet potato, chicken and cheese, or beef and carrots — that are lightly cooked in order to preserve their nutritional value. The staff builds a meal plan after you answer various questions about your cat, such as their current weight, age, health, and breed. You get the option to choose how frequently you want delivery (the subscription offered gives you 5% savings) and the opportunity to cancel anytime. The brand doesn’t use any GMO or artificial ingredients or antibiotics or hormones. Tom & Sawyer also uses locally sourced ingredients from Canadian farmers and businesses.

    The cons with this food are that shipping is only free in Southern Ontario and that their recipes are only beef, turkey, or chicken, so if your cat prefers fish, you’re out of luck.

    Pros
    • Handmade food from Toronto
    • Available in three flavours lightly cooked
    • Build a meal plan after answering questions about your cat
    • No GMO or artificial ingredients, antibiotics, or hormones
    • Use locally sourced ingredients from Canadian farms and businesses
    Cons
    • Shipping only free in Southern Ontario
    • No fish recipe options

    2. TLC Pet Food — Best Value

    TLC Pet Food Logo

    Recipes: Chicken and Atlantic salmon
    Food type: Dry
    Standout feature: Meat focused and for all life stages
    Size: 3 x 2.26-kg bags

    The best fresh cat food delivery in Canada for the money is TLC Pet Food. While it is expensive, it is less expensive than other comparable high-quality brands of cat food. It isn’t exactly fresh because it’s kibble, but it’s made with fresh ingredients that are meat focused from high-quality protein sources. Included are ingredients such as cranberries to maintain your cat’s urinary tract health, as well as pea fibre for digestive health, which can also help with hairballs. This kibble is suitable for cats of all ages — kittens up to senior cats — and free shipping is offered for most of Canada and the U.S.

    One issue is that there is only one recipe available, which is a chicken and Atlantic salmon flavour. It would be great if wet food was also offered along with the kibble.

    Pros
    • Less expensive than other, comparable high-quality cat foods
    • Made with high-quality, fresh ingredients
    • Includes cranberries for urinary tract health
    • Good for cats of all ages
    • Free delivery for most of Canada and the U.S.
    Cons
    • Only one recipe is available
    • Would be nice if wet food was offered

    3. Open Farm Cat Food — Premium Choice

     

    open farm logo

    *Use code PANBFCM to save 20% on any order, and 25% on any auto-order, up to $150! 

    Recipes: Multiple
    Food type: Dry or wet
    Standout feature: It is “100% obsessively sourced 100% of the time
    Size: Multiple

    Open Farm Cat Food is our premium choice pick because it offers dry and wet food options made using ethical sources. There are four flavours of dry food (turkey and chicken, salmon, whitefish, and lamb) and six wet food recipes (chicken, chicken and salmon, turkey, salmon, beef, and herring and mackerel). The food is manufactured in Minnesota, but everything else (developing, formulating, and distributing) occurs in Canada. All livestock used are sourced sustainably and humanely, and all other ingredients are gathered fresh and locally. No GMOs, antibiotics, hormones, or artificial ingredients are added.

    However, Open Farm is expensive, and all the cat food recipes contain a fair amount of plant-based carbohydrates and proteins, some of which might be unnecessary considering the nutritional supplements that are already added. The included lentils might cause stomach upset in some cats.

    Pros
    • Offers four flavours of dry food and six flavours of wet wood
    • Animal sources are gathered sustainably and humanely
    • No GMOs, hormones, antibiotics, or artificial ingredients
    • Ingredients are sourced fresh and locally
    Cons
    • Expensive
    • Many plant-based ingredients

    4. Smack Pet Food

    Smack Pet Food Logo

    Recipes: Pork, fish, or chicken and salmon
    Food type: Raw dehydrated food
    Standout feature: Dehydration process maintains high nutrition
    Size: 210 grams or 1.5 kg

    Smack Pet Food is manufactured in Winnipeg and offers raw dehydrated food for cats in three different flavours: pork, wild Pacific fish, and chicken and wild salmon. This food isn’t exactly fresh, but Smack takes free-range and wild chicken and salmon and dehydrates them while fresh and raw using gentle low-temperature air drying. You can feed it to your cat as dry kibble, or you can add warm water to rehydrate it into more of a stew texture. Smack doesn’t include any artificial ingredients and offers a 60-day money-back guarantee.

    However, it is expensive, and if your cat finds the food too hard, it doesn’t always rehydrate well.

    Pros
    • Three recipes of raw, dehydrated food
    • Free-range chicken and wild-caught salmon
    • Uses fresh ingredients that are dehydrated using gentle, low-temperature air-drying
    • Feed dry or rehydrate for a stew-like texture
    • 60-day money-back guarantee
    Cons
    • Expensive
    • Doesn’t always rehydrate

    5. PetzLove Pet Food

    PetzLove Pet Food logo

    Recipes: High protein or fish
    Food type: Dry
    Standout feature: Raw ingredients sourced in Canada
    Size: 0.9 or 1.8 kgs

    PetzLove Pet Food offers dry kibble that is available in two sizes and two recipes: Proteinest (high protein with chicken, turkey, and trout) and Áal (salmon and cod). All ingredients are locally sourced in order to support Canada’s agricultural industry, and you can feed it to cats at all life stages. The company uses free-range chicken and wild-caught fish for protein sources, and you can have the food delivered free across Canada if you spend at least $100. Alternatively, if you’re in or near Markham, Ontario, you can pick it up there.

    The problem is that there are only two flavours for cats, and it would be nice to see more recipes. Also, if your cat has a food allergy or sensitivity to chicken, both recipes include chicken.

    Pros
    • Available in two sizes and two flavours
    • Ingredients locally sourced in Canada
    • Good for all life stages
    • Free-range chicken and wild-caught fish
    Cons
    • Could use more recipe options for cats
    • Both recipes have chicken

    6. Freshpet Cat Food

    Freshpet Cat Food Logo

    Recipes: Chicken or beef
    Food type: Wet and dry
    Standout feature: Steam-cooked refrigerated food
    Size: 454-gram bag or roll

    Freshpet Cat Food is an American company that ships to Canada. It uses raw ingredients that are gently steamed at low temperatures to help retain the nutrients. There are three recipes for kibble (chicken and beef, chicken, and a grain-free chicken) and two recipes for wet food (chicken and beef and grain-free chicken and beef). The wet food is pâté stored by being rolled up, and it’s all-natural without any added preservatives and antibiotics. Freshpet sources 97% of its ingredients from the U.S. and Canada.

    The flaws with Freshpet are that it is not a Canadian company and that some pets have experienced stomach upset with this food. Also, there’s only chicken and beef for recipe options, and it would be great to have more to choose from.

    Pros
    • Ingredients are gently steamed at a low temperature
    • Three kibble recipes and two pâté recipes
    • All-natural without added preservatives or antibiotics
    • 97% of ingredients are sourced from the U.S. and Canada
    Cons
    • Not a Canadian company
    • Not enough recipes to choose from
    • Some pets have experienced stomach upset

    divider-cat

    Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose the Best Fresh Cat Food Delivery

    If you’re new to fresh food delivery services, you might have a few questions about whether it’s worth the expense. Here, we go over a few points to answer potential questions that you might have.

    What Are the Disadvantages?

    If you sign up for a fresh food pet service, it’s guaranteed that you’ll be paying more than what you pay at the grocery or pet store. Most of these companies use organic and free-range food that is locally sourced and humanely gathered. The production method for a few of these companies is also making it by hand, which increases the cost, along with the use of high-quality ingredients.

    Many of these foods need to be stored in the refrigerator or freezer, which can take up quite a bit of space. If you make the mistake of leaving it out too long, that’s good food and money going in the trash.

    Finally, most of these companies are relatively small scale and don’t offer much selection in flavours. If your cat has an allergy to chicken or beef, you won’t have much else to choose from, since many of these companies seem to exclusively use these protein sources.

    Is It Better Than the Usual Dry and Wet Food?

    There are many dry and wet cat foods that are manufactured by large companies that are good for your cat, but the fresh food option is definitely a healthier one comparatively. These foods have all been formulated by experts in the field, including animal nutritionists and veterinarians, who know the right balance of nutrients to keep your cat in top health.

    It’s also a healthier option than cooking food for your cat yourself, as you might miss out on a few of the essential vitamins and minerals that your cat needs.

    What Should You Look For in Fresh Cat Food Delivery?

    Tabby cat eating wet food
    Image Credit: thodonal88, Shutterstock

    Pricewise, they are all relatively equal. However, you’ll want to read through each company’s website (especially the About Us and FAQs pages) for the details that can make or break your decision. First, if your cat prefers fish, not all these companies have fish recipes, so that’s something to check.

    Read the ingredient list of the recipe of the company that you’re considering. Show it to your vet to get an expert opinion from someone you trust.

    See how easy it is to get out of the subscription service if it comes to that, and check the delivery options. Most of these companies enable you to fine-tune how often you receive the deliveries, which can be helpful if you don’t have a ton of space in your fridge.

    Is It Worth It?

    This depends on you. If your cat doesn’t have any medical conditions, you can afford it, and you’ve spoken to your vet about your interest in these kinds of foods and they are on board, it can be a great option. While fresh foods are quite expensive, they can work wonders for some cats. It can be particularly helpful if you’ve been considering making your cat homemade food yourself but don’t have the time.

    Many of these companies also have a small ecological footprint and are primarily using sustainable ingredients and gathering the protein sources humanely. Knowing that your cat is eating high-quality food without any artificial ingredients may give you peace of mind. But remember to speak to your vet before making the switch.

    divider-paw

    Conclusion

    Tom & Sawyer is our favourite fresh cat food delivery service in Canada, with its delicious recipes of fresh, minced food that is lightly cooked to preserve its nutritional value. It also only uses locally sourced ingredients from Canadian farmers and businesses. TLC Pet Food dry kibble is only made with fresh ingredients from high-quality protein sources, and it’s comparatively cheaper than some of the other options. Finally, Open Farm Cat Food offers dry and wet food options using only sustainably and humanely collected ingredients.

    Many cat owners swear that fresh cat food has changed their cat’s health around, so if it fits your budget and your vet agrees, it’s a win-win — fresh cat food delivered directly to your door!


    Featured Image Credit: sophiecat, Shutterstock

    Our vets

    Want to talk to a vet online?

    Whether you have concerns about your dog, cat, or other pet, trained vets have the answers!

    Our vets