Pet Keen is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Home > Cats > 10 Best Cat Foods at PetSmart in 2024 – Reviews & Top Picks

10 Best Cat Foods at PetSmart in 2024 – Reviews & Top Picks

a Norwegian forest cat eating from a glass bowl

With over 1,500 stores and a robust online marketplace, PetSmart is accessible to every pet owner. The product selection makes them a fantastic resource for cat owners. Regardless of budget, PetSmart makes finding quality food for your cat is as easy as possible.

However, narrowing down what food to choose for your cat can be difficult. There are thousands of products on the market, and while most of them are likely to meet your cat’s nutritional needs, they aren’t all created equal for all cats. These reviews bring together the 10 best cat foods that PetSmart carries to make it easier for you to pick the best food for your kitty.

divider-cat

A Glance at Our Winners in 2024

Image Product Details
Best Overall
Winner
Applaws Tuna Fillet Cat Food Applaws Tuna Fillet Cat Food
  • 82% moisture
  • Highly palatable
  • Limited ingredient formula
  • Best Value
    Second place
    Purina Pro Turkey & Rice Cat Food Purina Pro Turkey & Rice Cat Food
  • 80% moisture
  • Fully balanced
  • Meaty chunks in gravy
  • Premium Choice
    Third place
    Royal Canin Cat Food Royal Canin Cat Food
  • Aids in hairball management
  • Formulated to reduce litter box odors
  • Moderate calorie formula is ideal for indoor cats
  • Best for Kittens
    Nulo Medalseries Cod Kitten Food Nulo Medalseries Cod Kitten Food
  • Antioxidants support immunity
  • Contains probiotics to support digestive health
  • Ideal nutrient profile to support kitten development
  • Nature’s Variety Cat Food Nature’s Variety Cat Food
  • Good source of omega fatty acids
  • Contains probiotics for digestive health
  • Partial raw food without home preparation needed
  • The 10 Best Cat Foods at PetSmart

    1. Applaws Tuna Fillet with Shrimp in Broth Cat Food – Best Overall

    Applaws Tuna Fillet with Shrimp in Broth

    Primary Protein: Tuna
    Protein Content: 77.8%
    Fat Content: 5.5%
    Fiber Content: 5.5%

    The best overall cat food at PetSmart is the Applaws Tuna Fillet with Shrimp in Broth wet food. This food features 77.8% protein on a dry matter basis, and it’s low in fat at only 5.5% on a dry matter basis. It consists of 82% moisture and contains only four ingredients. It has no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives. It is high in omega fatty acids, making this a good choice for supporting skin, coat, and joint health.

    This food is intended to be fed in conjunction with a portion of dry food as it may not contain all necessary nutrients on its own. It is highly palatable, though, and the limited ingredient formula makes it a good option for cats with food sensitivities.

    Pros
    • 77.8% protein, 5.5% fat, and 5.5% fiber on a dry matter basis
    • 82% moisture
    • Limited ingredient formula
    • No artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives
    • High in omega fatty acids
    • Highly palatable
    Cons
    • Intended to be fed in conjunction with dry food

    2. Purina Pro Complete Essentials Turkey & Rice Cat Food – Best Value

    Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials Turkey & Rice

    Primary Protein: Turkey
    Protein Content: 55%
    Fat Content: 10%
    Fiber Content: 7.5%

    The best cat food at PetSmart for the money is the Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials Turkey & Rice wet food. This food meets AAFCO guidelines for cat food and features meaty chunks in a tasty gravy. It contains 55% protein, 10% fat, and 7.5% fiber on a dry matter basis, as well as 80% moisture. Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials Turkey & Rice is also a good source of omega fatty acids and vitamin A to support skin and coat health. This recipe is fully balanced on its own and doesn’t have to be fed in conjunction with other foods.

    The formula and packaging of this food were recently changed, and some people have reported their cats finding the new formula less palatable since they were used to the old formula. However, this doesn’t seem to be an issue for cats who were not already used to the old formula.

    Pros
    • Best value
    • Meaty chunks in gravy
    • 55% protein, 10% fat, and 7.5% fiber on a dry matter basis
    • 80% moisture
    • Good source of omega fatty acids and vitamin A
    • Fully balanced
    Cons
    • Recent formula change

    3. Royal Canin Indoor Adult Cat Food – Premium Choice

    Royal Canin Indoor Adult Cat Food

    Primary Protein: Chicken
    Protein Content: 27%
    Fat Content: 11%
    Fiber Content: 5.7%

    The Royal Canin Indoor Adult Cat Food is the premium pick for cat food at PetSmart. This food contains 27% protein, 11% fat, and 5.7% fiber, with chicken meal as the first ingredient. It meets the AAFCO guidelines for cat food and is a moderate-calorie formula to help maintain a healthy weight in indoor cats. It’s formulated to reduce stool odors, making for fewer stinky litter boxes. It also aids in hairball management and helps prevent tartar buildup on the teeth.

    Some people have reported their cats vomiting after trying this food. It is important to remember, though, that cats should be slowly transitioned over to new foods to prevent this from occurring.

    Pros
    • 27% protein, 11% fat, and 5.7% fiber
    • Moderate calorie formula is ideal for indoor cats
    • Formulated to reduce litter box odors
    • Aids in hairball management
    • May help prevent tartar buildup on the teeth
    Cons
    • Premium price
    • Must transition slowly to prevent stomach upset

    4. Nulo Medalseries Cod Kitten Food – Best for Kittens

    Nulo Medalseries Cod Kitten Food

    Primary Protein: Cod
    Protein Content: 36.5%
    Fat Content: 16%
    Fiber Content: 4.5%

    The best kitten food at Petsmart is the Nulo Medalseries Cod Kitten Food, which contains 36.5% protein, 16% fat, and 4.5% fiber. It contains probiotics to support digestive health and antioxidants to support health and immunity. It’s free of corn, soy, wheat, grains, artificial colors, preservatives, and artificial flavors. It contains an ideal nutrient profile to support healthy growth and development in kittens. It’s also palatable, and many people report their kittens gulping down this food. It does sell for a premium price, though.

    Pros
    • 36.5% protein, 16% fat, and 4.5% fiber
    • Contains probiotics to support digestive health
    • Antioxidants support immunity
    • Free of corn, soy, wheat, grains, and artificial additives
    • Ideal nutrient profile to support kitten development
    • Highly palatable
    Cons
    • Premium price

    5. Nature’s Variety Instinct Raw Boost Cat Food

    Nature’s Variety Instinct Raw Boost Cat Food

    Primary Protein: Chicken
    Protein Content: 41%
    Fat Content: 22%
    Fiber Content: 3.5%

    The Nature’s Variety Instinct Raw Boost Cat Food is an excellent option if you’re interested in a partially raw diet without having to prepare it at home. This dry food contains a coating of raw food powder on each kibble, and it contains 41% protein, 22% fat, and 3.5% fiber. It’s a good source of omega fatty acids and contains probiotics to support digestive health. It’s free of corn, wheat, soy, potato, by-product meal, and artificial colors and preservatives. This food is suitable for cats of all life stages, but the high calorie and fat content makes this food more appropriate for young and active cats.

    Pros
    • Partial raw food without home preparation needed
    • 41% protein, 22% fat, and 3.5% fiber
    • Good source of omega fatty acids
    • Contains probiotics for digestive health
    • Free of corn, wheat, soy, potato, by-product meal, and artificial colors and preservatives
    Cons
    • Premium price
    • High in fat and calories

    6. Made by Nacho Chicken, Duck, & Quail Recipe

    Made by Nacho Chicken, Duck, & Quail Recipe

    Primary Protein: Chicken
    Protein Content: 32%
    Fat Content: 18%
    Fiber Content: 4%

    The Made by Nacho Chicken, Duck, & Quail Recipe is a protein-rich food that contains chicken, duck, quail, and multiple nutrient-dense ingredients. It’s formulated with 32% protein, 18% fat, and 4% fiber, making it a good pick for active adult cats. It contains probiotics and prebiotics for digestive health and amino acids for muscle development. It’s also a good source of omega fatty acids.

    Bone broth makes this food highly palatable and higher in moisture than most dry foods at 10% moisture content. It’s free of corn, wheat, soy, and artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives. Made by Nacho Chicken, Duck, & Quail Recipe is calorie-dense and high in fat, and can cause weight gain in older cats or cats with low activity levels.

    Pros
    • 32% protein, 18% fat, and 4% fiber
    • Contains probiotics and prebiotics for digestive health
    • Good source of amino acids and omega fatty acids
    • Higher in moisture than most dry foods
    • Free of corn, wheat, soy, and artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives
    Cons
    • High in fat and calories

    7. Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Chicken Feast Cat Food

    Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Chicken Feast

    Primary Protein: Chicken
    Protein Content: 50%
    Fat Content: 10%
    Fiber Content: 7.5%

    The Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Chicken Feast is an affordable wet food option for kitties that like lots of gravy. On a dry matter basis, this food contains 50% protein, 10% fat, and 7.5% fiber. It has 82% moisture and features meaty chunks in gravy. This food is palatable and meets all the basic nutritional needs of adult cats, although it does contain soy and wheat.

    This is not a nutrient-dense food, so the feeding requirements are relatively high. This food is best fed in conjunction with a portion of dry food to ensure your cat’s nutritional needs are met without your cat overeating.

    Pros
    • Budget-friendly
    • 50% protein, 10% fat, and 7.5% fiber on a dry matter basis
    • 82% moisture
    • Meaty chunks in a palatable gravy
    • Meets all basic nutritional needs
    Cons
    • Contains soy and wheat
    • Not nutrient-dense

    8. Hill’s Science Diet Healthy Roasted Chicken & Rice Medley

    Hill’s Science Diet Healthy Cuisine Roasted Chicken & Rice Medley

    Primary Protein: Chicken
    Protein Content: 36.7%
    Fat Content: 20%
    Fiber Content: 13.3%

    The Hill’s Science Diet Healthy Cuisine Roasted Chicken & Rice Medley canned food contains 36.7% protein, 20% fat, and 13.3% fiber on a dry matter basis. It has meaty chunks in a tasty broth, which brings it to 85% moisture, and it is a good source of antioxidants to support immunity. The high-quality protein sources support energy in your cat, although the high-fat content makes this food a better option for active cats. It’s made with easily digested ingredients for better digestive health and nutrient absorption. This food contains wheat and soy, and it is designed for cats from ages 1–6, so it’s not ideal for kittens or older adult cats.

    Pros
    • 36.7% protein, 20% fat, and 13.3% fiber on a dry matter basis
    • 85% moisture
    • Good source of antioxidants for immune health
    • Supports energy levels in active cats
    • Made with easily digested ingredients
    Cons
    • Contains wheat and soy
    • Designed only for cats from ages 1–6 years

    9. Tiki Cat Pate Tuna & Crab Recipe in Tuna Broth Cat Food

    Tiki Cat Pate Tuna & Crab Recipe in Tuna Broth

    Primary Protein: Tuna
    Protein Content: 66.7%
    Fat Content: 11.1%
    Fiber Content: 5.6%

    The Tiki Cat Pate Tuna & Crab Recipe in Tuna Broth is a wet food that contains 66.7% protein, 11.1% fat, and 5.6% fiber on a dry matter basis. It contains 82% moisture and is made from real dolphin-safe tuna and crab. It’s free of fruits, vegetables, grains, or artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives. It’s a balanced food that is highly palatable to most cats.

    This is a premium-priced food option. It has a strong fishy smell, so cats that don’t like seafood flavors are unlikely to find this food appealing.

    Pros
    • 66.7% protein, 11.1% fat, and 5.6% fiber on a dry matter basis
    • 82% moisture
    • Made from dolphin-safe tuna and real crab
    • Free of fruits, veggies, grains, and artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives
    Cons
    • Premium price
    • Strong smell

    10. Only Natural Pet PowerFunction Skin & Coat Cat Food

    Only Natural Pet PowerFunction Skin & Coat Dinner

    Primary Protein: Salmon
    Protein Content: 41%
    Fat Content: 13%
    Fiber Content: 4%

    The Only Natural Pet PowerFunction Skin & Coat Dinner is rich in omega fatty acids to support skin and coat health. It contains 41% protein, 13% fat, and 4% fiber, as well as 10% moisture, making it higher than many other dry foods. It contains nutrient-dense ancient grains and is free of legumes. This food is formulated by holistic vets and contains bites of freeze-dried fish meat. This food does sell for a premium price, so it may not suit all budgets. It’s a calorie-dense food, so it may not be ideal for older cats, overweight cats, or cats with low activity levels.

    Pros
    • Rich in omega fatty acids
    • 41% protein, 13% fat, and 4% fiber
    • Higher moisture content than many dry foods
    • Nutrient-dense ingredients
    • Formulated by holistic vets
    Cons
    • Premium price
    • Calorie dense
    • Not a good option for older or overweight cats or cats with low activity levels

    divider-cat

     

    Buyer’s Guide: Selecting the Best Cat Food at PetSmart

    Choosing the Right Food for Your Cat

    Choosing the best food for your cat is based on multiple factors. The top factor to consider is whether you think your cat will eat the food or not. Cats can be finicky, so choose a food that contains flavors and textures that your cat has shown a preference for. It may take trial and error to choose the perfect food for your cat.

    Your cat’s age and weight, as well as the presence of any health conditions, should all be considered. If you’re unsure if a food is appropriate for your cat, talk to your vet before trying it. Your vet will know if a food isn’t suitable for your cat’s needs.

    Reading Cat Food Labels

    Cat Food Protein Content

    Most adult cats require a minimum of 26% protein in their diet. Too little protein can lead to deficiencies, while too much protein can tax the kidneys, especially in cats who are predisposed to kidney problems. Some studies have indicated that healthy adult cats that don’t eat at least 40% dietary protein may begin losing muscle mass. Senior and elderly cats often need at least 50% protein in their diet to maintain muscle mass and overall health

    Cat Food Fat Content

    According to the AAFCO recommendations for adult cats, they should consume a minimum of 9% fat on a dry matter basis in their daily diet. Fats are needed for skin and coat health, as well as brain health and development, wound healing, cardiac health, immunity, weight maintenance, and organ function.

    Cat Food Fiber Content

    Fiber is essential for maintaining digestive health and promoting satiety, or a feeling of fullness, in your cat. Fiber is a carbohydrate, and cats tend to have relatively low carbohydrate needs since they are obligate carnivores. Aim to provide some fiber in your cat’s daily diet, but the average goal is to keep carbohydrates below 10% of the daily dietary intake. If your cat is having digestive difficulties or seems to struggle with satiety, talk to your vet about the options available to you.

    Cat Food Moisture

    Moisture, or water intake, is necessary for survival. However, cats tend to chronically drink too little water. Moisture in their food can help promote hydration, kidney function, and a healthy urinary tract. If your cat doesn’t drink much water, adding a portion of food that provides a good source of moisture can be an easy way to sneak fluid into your cat’s diet. Wet cat food is an excellent way to add moisture to your cat’s diet.

    Hepper 360 Cat Feeder, Stainless Steel, Anti-Chew...
    • NO MESS - The 360° tray on this cat food and water bowl set has a raised design to catch and...
    • WHISKER FRIENDLY - Shallow and wide metal containers with flat bottoms ensure your kitty can enjoy...
    • CHEW-SAFE MATERIALS - Kittens and cats love chewing on silicone and soft rubber - but it's a choking...

    High-quality cat food is an important part of fostering a long and healthy life for your cat but the right cat food and water dish will promote good posture, offer whisker relief, and aid in good digestion. The Hepper NomNom Cat Bowl is our favorite bowl since it offers all of the above and is beautifully crafted to meet modern home stylings. The wide tray design catches any food and water spills and the entire setup is dishwasher safe. Learn more about the Hepper NomNom Cat Bowl here.

    At Pet Keen, we’ve admired Hepper for many years and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!

    divider-cat

     

    Conclusion

    Did you see a food in these reviews that you feel might work for your cat? To recap, the best overall cat food available at PetSmart is the Applaws Tuna Fillet with Shrimp in Broth, which is a limited-ingredient formula that can help add moisture to your cat’s diet. The budget-friendly food pick is the Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials Turkey & Rice, which is affordable without sacrificing food quality. For dry food, the premium pick is the Royal Canin Indoor Adult Cat Food, which is specially formulated to meet the needs of your indoor kitty.


    Featured Image Credit: Astrid Gast, Shutterstock

    Our vets

    Want to talk to a vet online?

    Whether you have concerns about your dog, cat, or other pet, trained vets have the answers!

    Our vets