Pet Keen is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Home > Cats > 5 Best Halloween Cat Toys in 2024 – Reviews & Top Picks

5 Best Halloween Cat Toys in 2024 – Reviews & Top Picks

Cat halloween costume

Halloween is a great time of year for cats! Intelligent humans around the world have recognized the importance of providing their kitties with appropriate sorts of tribute to keep the peace, and Halloween provides the perfect opportunity to show your favorite feline friend that you care about its well-being. Read on for reviews of the 10 best Halloween cat toys and information about what to keep in mind when making a choice!


A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2024

Image Product Details
Best Overall
Goody Box Halloween Cat Toys and Treats Goody Box Halloween Cat Toys and Treats
  • Curated selection of toys and treats
  • 30% discount over individual purchase prices
  • Not a subscription plan
  • Best Value
    Second place
    Halloween Cat Tracks Toy Halloween Cat Tracks Toy
  • Super affordable option
  • Encourages physical activity
  • Includes a replacement for the top feathered toy
  • Premium Choice
    Third place
    Halloween Teaser Wand Cat Toy with Catnip Halloween Teaser Wand Cat Toy with Catnip
  • Sturdy plastic wand with easy-to-operate interface
  • Three fun teaser options
  • Features catnip-infused plush toys
  • 13-Day Halloween Advent Calendar with Toys 13-Day Halloween Advent Calendar with Toys
  • 13 individual toys for variety
  • Includes catnip-infused plush toys
  • Contains items designed to stimulate physical activity
  • 2-Story Halloween Cardboard Cat House Mansion 2-Story Halloween Cardboard Cat House Mansion
  • Features catnip-infused toys
  • Soft fabric to encourage cuddling
  • Crinkle stuffing to stimulate attack instincts
  • The 5 Best Halloween Cat Toys

    1. Goody Box Halloween Cat Toys and Treats — Best Overall

    Goody Box Halloween Cat Toys and Treats

    Toy type: Gift box
    Material: Polyester, synthetic fabric, treats

    Goody Box provides a fun Halloween-themed collection that’ll delight the devil in your favorite feline friend. It’s our choice for the best overall Halloween cat toy due to the variety of toys and treats included in this nicely curated box.

    The collection features six products: salmon-flavored treats, spider and plush donut toys, lobster and cheese crunchy treats, lickable tuna paste, and a scrunchy foldable play tunnel. Because it comes as a bundle, you’ll spend about 30% less than you would if you decided to purchase each item individually. It’s not a subscription, so you don’t have to cancel anything after you order!

    • Curated selection of toys and treats
    • 30% discount on individual purchase prices
    • Not a subscription plan
    • Doesn’t include a wand toy

    2. Halloween Cat Tracks Toy — Best Value

    Halloween Cat Tracks Toy

    Toy type: Track toy
    Material: Plastic

    The Halloween Cat Tracks Toy will keep your furry friend busy for hours. The tiered circular tower features three levels of fun with balls your favorite cat can smack and bat at until their heart’s content. Best of all, it’s affordable and our choice for the best Halloween cat toy for the money. A springy plush toy featuring a feather sits at the top of the toy, giving your cat something to torment with its feline prowess. The product has a replacement attachment for the top shaped like a spooky bat!

    • Super affordable option
    • Encourages physical activity
    • Includes a replacement for the top feathered toy
    • Made of plastic

    3. Halloween Teaser Wand Cat Toy with Catnip

    Halloween Teaser Wand Cat Toy with Catnip, 3 Count

    Toy type: Wand toys
    Material: Plastic, polyester

    The Halloween Teaser Wand Cat Toy comes with a sturdy plastic wand and three fun attachments: a bat/ghost combination, a pumpkin with an enticing feather, and a spider dangling from a spiderweb. All three contain catnip to elevate your buddy’s experience to nirvana-like levels of kitty bliss. The wand features backup toys that allow you to switch teasers, extending the toy’s life. Store the toys you aren’t using somewhere cool and dark, preferably in a nice airtight container, to ensure the catnip remains fresh for longer!

    • Sturdy plastic wand with easy-to-operate interface
    • Three fun teaser options
    • Features catnip-infused plush toys
    • Teasers attached by easily snappable polyester string

    4. 13-Day Halloween Advent Calendar with Toys

    13-Day Halloween Advent Calendar with Toys

    Toy type: Advent calendar
    Material: Cardboard, paper, catnip, plush fabric

    The 13-Day Halloween Advent Calendar is the perfect way to show your kitty how much you love it. The box contains 13 fun cat-friendly gifts, and you can provide a new one every day in the weeks before the spookiest holiday of the year to get your cat excited for the big day! It’s packed with kitty-approved products like plush toys, crinkly balls, teasers, balls with bells, and witches and devils with fluffy chase-inspiring tails. There are even a few plush toys stuffed full of catnip to take your feline’s celebration to the next level.

    • 13 individual toys for variety
    • Includes catnip-infused plush toys
    • Contains items designed to stimulate physical activity
    • Box includes relatively few options designed to encourage human-cat interaction

    5. 2-Story Halloween Cardboard Cat House Mansion

    2-Story Halloween Cardboard Cat House Mansion

    Toy type: Cat house
    Material: Cardboard

    This fun cat house mansion delivers Halloween-themed fun that adds just the right decorative touch to your home while giving your cat a fun toy to enjoy. Your furry buddy can hide on the inside of the “mansion” or stretch its back as it enjoys the scratching pad on the roof.

    The cat house is made of heavy-duty cardboard, and there’s probably not a cat alive that doesn’t love curling up in a cardboard box! Don’t worry if you have a hefty feline devil at home; the mansion can safely hold up to 50 pounds.

    • Made of corrugated cardboard
    • Provides enclosed box-like hideout
    • Included scratching pad
    • Replacement scratching pads not available


    Buyer’s Guide: Picking the Best Cat Toys for Halloween

    When selecting the ideal toy for your cat, there are several factors to keep in mind, including how your cat likes to play, their specific mental and physical stimulation needs, and your preferences. Below we’ll discuss a few of the essential elements to consider when picking a suitable cat toy for your furry companion.

    Why Do Cats Need Toys?

    Cats are natural predators that need physical and mental stimulation to remain happy and healthy. Cats that don’t get enough exercise often become overweight and are at increased risk for diseases related to obesity, arthritis, kidney disease, and diabetes. Indoor cats that have been spayed or neutered tend to gain weight easily. Toys encourage cats to get off the couch and move, which goes a long way to ensure your kitty maintains a healthy weight.

    Cats also need plenty of mental stimulation. Kitties that don’t get enough playtime often begin to suffer from boredom, anxiety, and other mental health conditions. Cats that are anxious or bored often resort to harmful or aggravating behaviors like repetitive licking or continuous meowing. Intelligent cats without mental stimulation pick up on ways to irritate their owner and engage in naughty behavior to elicit attention.

    Cats enjoy stimulating their minds as well as running, chasing objects, jumping, scratching, pouncing, and batting at things. A cat can indulge in its desire to chase things with a milk jug ring, but that activity won’t give them an opportunity to scratch or bat at things that fly through the air. Providing your cat with various toys allows them to meet all their instinctual needs.

    What Are Some of the Different Types of Toys to Consider

    Below we’ll point out the advantages and disadvantages of a few of the most popular cat toys.

    Our Pick for Best Catnip Toy:

    Well-designed toys will keep your cat happy and engaged. For a sturdy, fun toy that will look nice in your living room, we recommend Hepper’s Catnip Stick Toy! These toys are designed to look like prey and double-bagged to stand up to your cat’s sharpest claws and teeth. Plus, they’re filled with organic catnip and handmade in the USA.

    Hepper Stick Catnip Cat Kicker Toy
    • No Filler - Like all the best cat toys our is stuffed with 100% organic catnip. Cheap cat toys with...
    • Flexible Play - Simple plush shape is great for biting, scratching and pawing. It can start life as...
    • Durably Designed - Our cat safe toys are hand-stitched with a double-lined exterior construction for...

    At Pet Keen, we’ve admired Hepper for many years, and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!

    Wands and Teasers

    Wand toys and teasers are fantastic options that let your cat stalk, chase, pounce, stand on its hind legs, and bat at things. They are super flexible and give you many ways to interact with your cat. They tend to be relatively inexpensive, and you can often find options filled with catnip to elevate your feline’s experience to the next level of fun. You’ll need to put these teasers away when you’re not using them since they have long strings that can break.

    Laser Pointers

    cat plays with a laser pointer
    Image Credit: Seika Chujo, Shutterstock

    Laser pointers offer a less physically demanding way for you to interact with your cat. Your cat can still get all the running, jumping, pounding, and batting with a teaser or wand, but you don’t have to be as physically involved to have a good time. They’re great options for older pet owners who want to give their felines a fun physical workout. You’ll still need to provide a toy that your cat can catch. Kitties enjoy going after laser pointers, but being unable to grab their “prey” and give it a good shake can be frustrating. Laser pointers should never be pointed directly at your cat’s eyes, which can cause blindness.

    Balls and Tiny Rodents

    Small cat-sized balls can be fun for kitties to play with: the plastic kind with bells inside and the crinkly sort that make a fun rodent-like noise when batted around. Balls are usually quite affordable and often come in multipacks with other toys. They’re particularly useful if you’re away from home for long hours. Just leave a few out, and your cat will have something to entertain themselves. Small rodent-like toys work on the same concept.

    Plush Toys

    Plush toys give cats a fun way to entertain themselves when you’re not around. Most resemble a small rodent, and almost all feature catnip. You can even find options that allow you to put more catnip inside as needed, which can significantly extend the life of the toys. Most cats enjoy playing with plush toys on their own. However, some like to play “fetch” with their favorite plush toy and enjoy chasing the toy after you throw it!

    Food Puzzles

    Food puzzles provide cats with both mental and physical stimulation. You put a treat in the toy and let your cat smack and chase the puzzle until they manage to get hold of the food. They’re one of the best options for smart cats that have a tendency to become naughty when understimulated. Since your cat will also have to work to get their food, the toys ensure your feline gets extra exercise during the day, which can help keep their weight under control.

    Electronic and “Interactive” Toys

    Interactive toys run the gamut from robotic mice to whack-a-mole-style contraptions. They can be expensive and aren’t designed to encourage human-cat interaction, but they give your cat a fun way to stay active and mentally engaged when you’re not around. Keep in mind that these products are not a substitute for human-kitty playtime.


    cat playing on cat scratcher_Chewy_Unsplash
    Image Credit: Chewy, Unsplash

    Kitties that don’t have scratching posts often begin scratching chairs, sofas, and other upholstered items. While providing a good scratching post isn’t a surefire way to keep your pet from destroying your couch, it’ll significantly cut down on the destruction.

    Tunnels and Cardboard Houses

    Crinkly tunnels and houses provide cats with hours of fun, hiding places, and hidden cubby holes to wind down in. Tunnels are thin, flexible structures your cat can climb into. Some kitties enjoy using tunnels for games of hide and seek, while others find them perfect for napping. Cardboard “houses” are souped-up cardboard boxes, and most cats can barely wait to jump into any box that comes into the house. Cardboard cat houses often have a few extra special features, such as catnip-infused scratch pads.


    Some cats live for more than 20 years, and they never stop needing stimulation and enjoying the challenges of plush hunting. Interactive and electronic toys are the most expensive choices, while basic, time-tested options such as crinkle balls often come in affordable multipacks. Teasers and laser pointers provide a nice middle ground, and a sturdy used cardboard box can be an affordable alternative to a cardboard cat mansion or house. For plush toys, you can save a ton of money by using brands that let you refill the catnip instead of having to purchase a new toy.

    Your Cat’s Preferences

    While it’s tempting to choose toys based on what you think your cat needs, it’s more important to pay attention to the types of toys they actually enjoy playing with. Some cats love to chase things but will completely ignore crinkle balls. Others won’t bother with teasers but love to grab plush toys.

    Your Preferences

    Interacting with your cat is central to maintaining a strong bond. Entertaining your feline is critical in creating a solid relationship with your pet, but it’s also important to be realistic about your limitations. Teasers aren’t necessarily the best options if you’re busy and don’t have time to engage with your cat, and they aren’t great if you have mobility or balance limitations. Plush toys and interactive options provide cats with opportunities for self-directed play that’s great if you’re often away from home or too tired to run around with a teaser after a long day at work.



    The Halloween Cat Toys & Treats box takes the top spot in our review thanks to the fantastic variety of options included in the collection. The Halloween Cat Tracks Toy is an excellent budget option that’ll provide your cat with hours of entertainment. The Halloween Teaser Wand Cat Toy with Catnip, 3 Count, is a great interactive way to get your kitty moving. And the 13-Day Halloween Advent Calendar with Toys for Cats provides a sweet way for you and your feline to prepare for the best holiday of the year!

    Featured Image Credit: Anton27, Shutterstock

    Our vets

    Want to talk to a vet online?

    Whether you have concerns about your dog, cat, or other pet, trained vets have the answers!

    Our vets