Petkeen is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commision. Learn More

5 Best Places to Buy Cat Litter in the US (Online & In-Store)

Nicole Cosgrove

Cat on walter litter

Any cat owner knows that getting a good kitty litter is essential for a tidy home and comfortable cat. Conveniently, kitty litter is available at most supermarkets and pet stores, but these locations and the products they sell are not created equally.

In this article, we are going to cover the 5 best places to buy cat litter in the United States, both online and in-store. At the end, we also cover factors to consider when choosing the kitty litter store for yourself. Read on to learn more.

divider-multipetBest Places to Buy Cat Litter in the US Comparison

Chewy – Best Online Store

Pros
  • Many options to choose from
  • Store entirely for pet products
  • Affordable
  • Convenient
Cons
  • No store locations
  • Big company

Petco – Best In-store

Pros
  • Many options to choose from
  • Store entirely for pet products
  • Company that cares for pets
Cons
  • Big company

PetSmart – Biggest In-store Selection

Pros
  • Largest in-store kitty litter selection
  • Convenient
Cons
  • Big company
  • Some complaints about how they treat pets

Pretty Litter – Best Kitty Litter

Pros
  • Sells the best kitty litter
  • Affordable subscription service
  • Allows you to monitor cat health easily
Cons
  • Only one brand of kitty litter available
  • More expensive than most traditional kitty litter
  • No store locations

Amazon – Most Convenient

Pros
  • Fast shipping times
  • Many product options
  • Affordable
Cons
  • Big company
  • Store not dedicated to animals
  • No store locations

Best Places to Buy Cat Litter in the US

Here are the best places to shop for kitty litter in the United States:

1. Chewy.com – Best Online Location

Chewy is arguably the best place to buy cat litter in the United States online. The site has a huge selection to choose from, ranging from natural selections to convenient, big-name brands. Not to mention, Chewy prices are much more affordable than other online pet stores.

Chewy is highly convenient too. They offer fast shipping, and you can get anything your cat or other pets need. While ordering your cat’s litter, don’t forget her food and your dog’s flea medication. It’s that easy!

The downside to shopping at Chewy is that it is a big-name store. If you are someone who does not like to give their money to big corporations, you might not like shopping at Chewy for this reason. Nevertheless, Chewy is the best place to buy cat litter online simply because of its product range, affordability, and convenience.

Pros
  • Many options to choose from
  • Store entirely for pet products
  • Affordable
  • Convenient
Cons
  • No store locations
  • Big company

2. Petco – Best In-store Location

Although you can shop at Petco online or in-store, Petco is our favorite in-store location for buying kitty litter in the US. With over 1,500 stores across the United States, Puerto Rico, and Mexico, it is highly likely that you can find a Petco near you.

Petco is our favorite in-store location for kitty litter because they’re so convenient to find. Likewise, they sell a good range of products, and most of which are affordable and made with your cat’s health in mind. Like Chewy, Petco is a big-name brand, but they tend to care about animals more than other big-name retailers, which is why it is our favorite in-store location.

Although Petco is our favorite in-store location for purchasing kitty litter, feel free to look through their online options as well. There will be more kitty litter options online than at the store.

Pros
  • Many options to choose from
  • Store entirely for pet products
  • Company that cares for pets
Cons
  • Big company
  • Fewer selections than PetSmart

3. PetSmart – Biggest In-store Selection

PetSmart is similar to Petco, but it has a larger brand selection. You can shop online or in-store. If you prefer in-store shopping, you shouldn’t have much difficulty finding a PetSmart store near you. Much like Petco, there are over 1500 stores around the nation.

If you are looking for the highest number of kitty litter options at an in-store location, PetSmart is the choice for you. Although many of their kitty litter options will not be very natural or environmentally friendly, PetSmart wins out based on sheer number of options located at the store.

Pros
  • Largest in-store kitty litter selection
  • Convenient
Cons
  • Big company
  • Some complaints about how they treat pets

4. Pretty Litter – Best Kitty Litter

If you’re most concerned about your cat’s health and want a kitty litter that is both healthy and effective, you should try out Pretty Litter. Pretty Litter traps odors, eliminates moisture, and can help you keep an eye on your cat’s health.

Pretty Litter is only sold at prettylitter.com. So, you will have to shop online if you are interested in this kitty litter. Although this brand is more expensive than traditional kitty litters, it is healthy and helps you monitor your cat’s health. Not to mention, you can get it shipped to your door every month at a more affordable price than other kitty litter subscriptions.

Pros
  • Sells the best kitty litter
  • Affordable subscription service
  • Allows you to monitor cat health easily
Cons
  • Only one brand of kitty litter available
  • More expensive than most traditional kitty litter
  • No store locations

5. Amazon.com – Most Convenient

Of course, we could not make a list about the best places to buy kitty litter online without mentioning Amazon. As you know, Amazon has a plethora of products to choose from, including kitty litter. If you are short on kitty litter and need to get a bag in a pinch, Amazon may be a great solution.

Although Amazon is convenient, we placed it at the bottom of this list because it is not specifically made for animal products. Thus, the product might not be very healthy or environmentally friendly. Even with that in mind, Amazon may be a great choice if you need to get kitty litter delivered to your house fast.

Pros
  • Fast shipping times
  • Many product options
  • Affordable
Cons
  • Big company
  • Store not dedicated to animals
  • No store locations

How to Pick Out a Store for Kitty Litter

To make this list of the five best US stores for shopping for kitty litter, we considered four factors: number of options, price, cat-mindedness, and convenience. We recommend considering these four factors when you are selecting which store to shop at.

Wheat Cat Litter
Image Credit: Andriy Blokhin, Shutterstock

Number of Options

It’s always best to shop at a store that has many kitty litter options. That way, you are more likely to find the kitty litter your cat likes than if you were to go somewhere with fewer options.

If you know that your cat only likes a specific type of kitty litter, we recommend looking up locations that sell that brand. That way, you can ensure that the store you go to carries it. If that’s the case for you, it doesn’t so much matter how many kitty litter options the store sells, as long as they carry the brand you need.

Price

Although most stores sell kitty litters at the same relative price, always shop around to make sure you are getting the best bargain. You don’t want to buy kitty litter for an upcharge price simply because of the store you are purchasing it from.

Consider value programs, memberships, and coupons the store carries as well. That way, you can save even more money. Given that you must buy kitty litter so frequently, heavily considering price before selecting a store can help you save big time over the cat’s entire life.

Cat-Mindedness

Even though you can get kitty litter at grocery stores and other places that are not specifically geared towards animals, we recommend shopping for kitty litter at stores with a cat-focused niche, such as a pet supply store.

Although the prices for kitty litter purchased at pet stores may be slightly more expensive, it assures that there are workers on hand who can help you pick out the best kitty litter for your cat. Plus, many of these stores also have resources to further educate you on the matter.

Not to mention, stores focused specifically on cats and animals are more likely to have pet-safe products that are made from non-toxic materials.

Cats Eat Litter
Image Credit: Serhii Ivashchuk, Shutterstock

Convenience

Because you will have to always have kitty litter on hand, it’s a good idea to purchase your kitty litter from a store that is convenient for you. You don’t want to have to drive across town every time you run out of kitty litter. Instead, select a kitty litter carrier that is either around where you live or can easily deliver the kitty litter to your door.

divider-multipetFinal Thoughts

Our favorite locations for purchasing kitty litter in the United States include Chewy, Petco, PetSmart, PrettyLitter, and Amazon. All five of these options allow you to purchase kitty litter online, whereas Petco and PetSmart also have in-store options.

We deem these the best stores for kitty litter shopping because they offer plenty of brands at an affordable price. More so, most of the stores are focused on cats and pets and put convenience at the forefront of the shopping experience.


Featured Image Credit: MelodicinD, Shutterstock

Nicole Cosgrove

Nicole is the proud mom of Baby, a Burmese cat and Rosa, a New Zealand Huntaway. A Canadian expat, Nicole now lives on a lush forest property with her Kiwi husband in New Zealand. She has a strong love for all animals of all shapes and sizes (and particularly loves a good interspecies friendship) and wants to share her animal knowledge and other experts' knowledge with pet lovers across the globe.