Pet Keen is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Home > Cats > 7 Best Cat Person Cat Food Alternatives in 2024: Reviews & Top Picks

7 Best Cat Person Cat Food Alternatives in 2024: Reviews & Top Picks

gray tabby scottish fold cat licking its lips after eating food from bowl

Cat Person is a pet food brand that delivers premium dry and wet cat food. Its recipes are simple, grain-free, and made with high-quality ingredients. However, Cat Person is not the only pet supply company that offers monthly deliveries of premium cat food. Several notable brands deliver cat food, and we anticipate more popping up as the demand for premium pet food continues to grow.

So, we have compared the best and most popular Cat Person cat food alternatives and have reviews that will help you make a more well-informed decision about the right brand. Let’s dig in!


A Quick Look at Our Favorites in 2024

Image Product Details
Best Overall
Smalls Human-Grade Cat Food Smalls Human-Grade Cat Food
  • Uses high-quality ingredients
  • Different texture options
  • Single-protein recipes
  • Second place
    Raised Right Fresh Cat Food Raised Right Fresh Cat Food
  • High-protein and low-carb recipes
  • Limited ingredients
  • Clean recall history
  • Third place
    Bobcat Raw Food Bobcat Raw Food
  • Variety of recipes
  • High in protein
  • Single source of protein
  • The 7 Cat Person Cat Food Alternatives

    1. Smalls Ground Bird Fresh Recipe vs. Cat Person Cat Food Chicken Shreds in Broth

    Smalls Ground Bird Fresh Recipe vs. Cat Person Cat Food Chicken Shreds in Broth

    First, we compared Smalls to Cat Person cat food. Both of these companies offer thoughtfully-made recipes with high-quality ingredients. All the ingredients are humanely harvested and sustainably sourced.

    Smalls currently has three recipes for its fresh cat food and three recipes for its freeze-dried raw food line. All the recipes are simple and only contain one type of meat, so it’s a great option for cats with food allergies. The fresh food has ground, shredded, and pate options to fit the varying preferences of all kinds of cats.

    Smalls does a great job of providing recipes for poultry-loving cats. However, its variety is limited, and it has only one beef recipe. It also does not sell any fish-based foods.

    This company offers doorstep delivery that’s easy to set up. You can also speak with their Cat Person Concierge Team if you run into any issues and typically receive a response within one business day.

    2. Raised Right Chicken Recipe vs. Cat Person Chicken Pate Cat Food

    Raised Right Chicken Recipe vs. Cat Person Chicken Pate Cat Food

    Although cat food delivery services do tend to be more expensive than directly shopping for food at a pet store, you don’t always have to spend a fortune for a subscription. Raised Right offers high-quality recipes at prices that are lower than those of its competitors.

    Like Cat Person, all the cat food recipes are high in protein and low in carbs and have been expertly formulated by veterinarians. They’re all limited-ingredient recipes, so you don’t have to worry about any unnecessary fillers, and cats with food sensitivities and allergies can enjoy them.

    The catch is that the selection of recipes is rather limited. You can select from four recipes, and all the recipes contain either chicken or turkey. You won’t find any other protein, such as beef, fish, or lamb. Also, the recipes are only for adult cats and don’t contain sufficient nutrients for kittens.

    Despite the lack of variety, Raised Right has a clean recall history and develops healthy recipes.

    3. Bobcat Raw Chicken Formula Cat Food vs. Cat Person Chicken Shreds in Broth

    Bobcat Raw Chicken Formula Cat Food vs. Cat Person Chicken Shreds in Broth

    Bobcat Raw Food is a small business in Texas that delivers raw cat food to your door. This company provides a decent variety of formulas, including chicken, pork, elk and venison, and rabbit; however, they currently do not offer any fish options, which Cat Person has a variety of.

    All the recipes are high in protein and only contain one source of protein so that cats with allergies can enjoy and easily digest the food. Bobcat Raw Food even has a pork recipe specifically formulated for picky eaters.

    Since you’re dealing with completely raw food, it’s important to make sure that you receive and store it in your freezer right away for food safety. So, it can be inconvenient if you have to wait for the delivery to arrive.

    Bobcat Raw Food doesn’t offer any guarantees that all their food will arrive fully frozen. Although they pack their food to help keep the food cold, it can still arrive partially thawed.

    4. Darwin’s Natural Selections Turkey Recipe vs. Cat Person Turkey & Chicken Pate

    Darwin’s Natural Selections Turkey Recipe vs. Cat Person Turkey & Chicken Pate copy

    Darwin’s Natural Pet Products offers raw food for cats of all ages, which we love and think is a great option if you have a kitten. All the recipes are minimally processed and don’t contain any grains, hormones, or chemical preservatives. The meats are all pasture-raised, free-range, or cage-free, and the vegetables are all organic.

    Darwin’s also offers a special kidney support formula specifically made for cats with kidney disease. Once you submit a veterinarian’s prescription to them, they can supply you with this special recipe.

    This pet food company also sells dog food that contains various protein sources, such as beef, chicken, duck, and lamb. The cat food selection is rather limited and currently only has recipes containing chicken or turkey unlike Cat Person that offers a wide variety of poultry, seafood, and beef. So, we hope to see more recipes develop in the next couple of years.

    What is important to you, whether it is the need for kidney support or variety, will help you choose between these two excellent cat food companies. We honestly think you can’t go wrong with either.

    5. Savage Cat Food Raw Food vs. Cat Person Chicken Pate

    Savage Cat Food Raw Food vs. Cat Person Chicken Pate

    Savage Cat Food is another pet food company that delivers raw food. It always ships its food on Mondays and provides tracking information so that you can know when to expect to receive the delivery, which isn’t always ideal, especially when compared to the ease of Cat Person and their delivery service.

    Since the food is all raw and frozen, it’s important to make sure that someone can get the delivery and store it right away. The food has a relatively long storage time and can stay in the freezer for up to 2 years.

    This cat food company offers three raw recipes: chicken, rabbit, and duck. The chicken is organic, and the rabbits and ducks are humanely raised. The recipes are low in carbohydrates and don’t contain any vegetables.

    As with several other cat food delivery services, we were a little disappointed with the lack of variety. However, Savage Cat Food’s recipes are thoughtfully made using high-quality ingredients. At the end of the day, we’d like to see a small selection of cat food made right over a large selection of poor-quality food.

    6. Just Food For Cats Fish & Chicken Fresh Cat Food vs. Cat Person Salmon & Tuna

    Just Food For Cats Fish & Chicken Fresh Cat Food vs. Cat Person Salmon & Tuna

    Just Cats currently has just one recipe for cats. Fortunately, the recipe is well-made and contains healthy ingredients. It’s grain-free and doesn’t contain any preservatives or growth hormones. Because it’s such a clean formula, it’s easily digestible for cats with food allergies or sensitivities. However, it’s not suitable for young kittens, which Cat Person Salmon & Tuna recipe is!

    Since Just Food For Dogs has many different recipes for dogs, we’re hopeful about seeing more cat food added to the lineup in the future. In the meantime, you can supplement the cat food with Just Cats’ salmon bark treats.

    When it comes to choosing between Just for Cats and Cat Person, they each have pros and cons, but we’ve said it before, and we will say it again: we love how much variety Cat Person provides, and they also have a wider selection of treats.

    7. Open Farm Salmon Recipe vs. Cat Person Salmon & Tuna Dry Cat Food

    Open Farm Salmon Recipe vs. Cat Person Salmon & Tuna Dry Cat Food

    Open Farm offers a larger variety of cat food that can be delivered to your door. You can select from dry cat food and wet cat food made with various meat sources, such as beef, chicken, turkey, and salmon. They have a similar variety of options to Cat Person, which is why we have decided to compare the two!

    This pet food company is very transparent about its ingredients. All the ingredients are 100% traceable, and the packaging comes with a code that you can look up to find where they were farmed and harvested. Although we love Cat Person cat food and know they use high-quality ingredients, we feel Open Farm’s ethic and transparency are hard to beat!

    Because of its close attention to detail, Open Farms cat food tends to be relatively expensive. The company does offer an auto-ship discount, but it’s not a very significant discount. Despite being pricey, it can be worth it if you value knowing exactly where the ingredients in your cat’s food are coming from and that all farmers and growers use humane and ethical practices.


    Buyer’s Guide: Choosing The Best Cat Person Cat Food Alternatives

    Now that we’ve reviewed some of the most popular cat food delivery subscription services, here’s some more helpful information on things to look for when deciding on a pet food subscription comparable to Cat Person.

    Recipe Quality

    Not all cat food subscription services offer high-quality food. So, make sure to thoroughly research the recipes before selecting them. Since cats are obligate carnivores, the recipe should consist mainly of protein and have minimal carbohydrates.

    The food should also contain high-quality ingredients and not have any artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives. If the pet company doesn’t offer recipes with premium ingredients, then there’s really very little point in paying the extra costs for its food delivery service. After all, you can always opt to auto-ship cat food from online pet retailers, such as Chewy, if you’re just looking for convenient food delivery.

    Some delivery services can even be scams. To check for the legitimacy of the company, search for independent reviews. You can also look up any recalls that the company has had. Another tell-tale sign of a scam company is the “About Us” page on the website. The site should have thorough and detailed information on its history and formation and any affiliations with quality control organizations, such as Certified Humane or Ocean Wise.


    A good pet food subscription service should have the type of food that your cat needs and enjoys eating. It’s better to work with companies that are mindful of food sensitivities and allergies.

    Delivery Schedule

    Make sure that the delivery schedule is flexible and provides options for you to skip months. The last thing you want is to be overstocked with fresh cat food that has a short shelf life. Many subscription pet food companies also offer options to temporarily halt an order or ship to a temporary address.

    Overall, look for a company that’s flexible so that you’ll always have just the right amount of food sent to you.

    Hepper 360 Cat Feeder, Stainless Steel, Anti-Chew...
    • NO MESS - The 360° tray on this cat food and water bowl set has a raised design to catch and...
    • WHISKER FRIENDLY - Shallow and wide metal containers with flat bottoms ensure your kitty can enjoy...
    • CHEW-SAFE MATERIALS - Kittens and cats love chewing on silicone and soft rubber - but it's a choking...

    Pet parents are faced with a few challenges when it comes to selecting new food and water bowls for their feline companions. The Hepper NomNom Cat Bowl combines cat-friendly features, such as shallow bowls and slight elevation that promote whisker relief, good posture, and digestion, with a beautiful modern design geared to keep floors free of mess during meal time. This bowl is entirely dishwasher safe, making life as a pet parent as simple as possible. Click here to learn why the Hepper NomNom Cat Bowl is right for you and your cat.

    At Pet Keen, we’ve admired Hepper for many years and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!



    After finishing up our comparisons, we noticed that Smalls really has a lot to offer. Smalls provides high-quality recipes in various textures, and its delivery system is easy to use which makes them a great alternative to Cat Person. We also like Raised Right because it’s a more affordable option and a great way for newcomers to dive into the world of subscription pet food. If you are looking for dry food and don’t mind splurging on your cat, we do recommend you check out Open Farm. We love their variety of kibble options and their vision.

    Feeding your cat high-quality fresh food is a great way to give you peace of mind in knowing that your cat’s eating a healthy diet. We expect to see more brands appear and are excited to see how cats will have more access to nutritious, premium food.

    Featured Image Credit: P Stock, Shutterstock

    Our vets

    Want to talk to a vet online?

    Whether you have concerns about your dog, cat, or other pet, trained vets have the answers!

    Our vets